Brendan Devenney with his sons Senán and Lúcás after a county win. ©INPHO

'We weren’t ready to take one of those big sides' - Donegal champs set to change script

Since the competition began, only two Donegal teams have won the Ulster club. St Eunan’s are the latest to go for it.

IT SEEMS KIND of crazy that for all the talent that has come out of the county, Donegal have such a poor record in the Ulster club football championship.

And yet, it was because of Donegal clubs that the provincial series got up and running.

There was a time in the mid-60s when county champions began arranging challenge matches against each other. This soon took on a bit of structure, with an unofficial Ulster championship staged.

In 1966, a St Joseph’s team, an amalgamation of Aodh Ruadh Ballyshannon and Realt na Mara of Bundoran, won the first of these, beating St John’s of Belfast in the final, 1-10 to 3-3. Brian McEniff was their guiding light.

The year after they defended the title, beating Crossmaglen Rangers in the final, with a patented Ulster club scoreline of 0-9 to 0-8.

By then, Croke Park had got the message. Clubs wanted to keep going outside their county boundaries and so, for the 1968 season, official provincial series were hosted.

In the first Ulster edition, St Joseph’s made the final, but were beaten 0-8 to 0-5 by Derry’s Bellaghy in Dungannon.

They eventually snapped up a title in 1975.

But apart from Gaoth Dobhair mounting an incredible raid and winning the 2018 Ulster club, that’s been the lot of Donegal representatives.

Killybegs, Naomh Conaill and Glenswilly have all been beaten in deciders, but they haven’t been regular challengers.

As market leaders in their own county, winners of the Dr Maguire Cup 17 times, with 13 spins in the Ulster club, St Eunan’s have not even marched behind the parade on Ulster club final day.

If it happens for them this year, the Letterkenny club will have to do it the hard way and go through the reigning Ulster club champions Scotstown (Saturday, 7.15pm at Brewster Park, Enniskillen).

Brendan Devenney won no fewer than six county titles as a player with Eunan’s and two more in manager and coaching roles. He set the scoring record in a final with 0-14 in the ’99 win over Aodh Ruadh. He was captain for two of them and man of the match twice.

After injury prevented him from playing through his mid-30s, he went into management and, along with Michael McGeehin and Eamon O’Boyle in 2012, managed the team to a county title, back in as a coach in 2024. 

He doesn’t need long to advance his theories on why they struggled to build on their success outside their county.

“At that time there was a real hardened sense of GAA in the north. They represented something. And most years we went in, Crossmaglen beat us,” he recalls.

“Donegal football was, if you like, a much ‘friendlier’ version of what else was in the north. The rest of Ulster was teak tough and Donegal club football was like the senior team of the time; open and looking to play, looking to out-score you. It didn’t have the tough template that you need, especially in the Ulster club at wintertime. Particularly when you are playing the likes of Cross.”

brendan-devenney-2812005 Devenney in his playing days. ©INPHO ©INPHO

There are no easy games in the Ulster club, but St Eunan’s seemed to get particularly seasoned teams, such as Bellaghy and Crossmaglen, with regularity.

“We were getting a wee bit closer each time but the sea-change, how Gaoth Dobhair won it and Naomh Conaill came close, was the introduction of the blanket defence and organisation in Donegal football as a whole,” says Devenney.

“That meant then that instead of a Donegal team going in and out, never dominating in the county, then coming up against a side that are there most years… You knew now how to sit tight and find your way into the game.

“If the blanket defence was there in the early 2000s with some of those St Eunan’s teams, they could have made a final or two. We had plenty of good players. But we weren’t ready to take one of those big sides.”

He continues, “What I mean by that is look at the year Gaoth Dobhair won it (2018). Who did they beat in the semi-final? Crossmaglen.

“And what happened is Cross had lost their unbelievable power that they had in the previous generation. And the tactics of Gaoth Dobhair, they just swamped them that day and pulled them into their counter-attack. That’s the evolution in the change.”

The current team have a bit about them, but a few questions remain.

In their 2024 campaign, they were a point up on Errigal Ciaran in the preliminary round when they ended up losing by three points after a late scoring splurge from Ben McDonnell and Tommy Canavan.

This year, they had Fermanagh champions Erne Gaels and won 1-14 to 0-10. Conor O’Donnell junior kicked 1-10 by himself, but Erne Gaels kicked a ridiculous 15 wides.

There’s no doubting they have talent. This Saturday will be a fascinating battle between two of the best five goalkeepers in the country, with Rory Beggan of Scotstown and Shaun Patton of Eunan’s.

shaun-patton Shaun Patton. Laszlo Geczo / INPHO Laszlo Geczo / INPHO / INPHO

Thereafter, they have the experienced Caolan Ward at full-back, the clever Conor O’Donnell senior at centre back, the prolific Conor O’Donnell junior (you read that right) in the inside forward line, and Mr Perpetual Motion in Ciaran Moore knitting together the moves in the same line as Shane O’Donnell.

They will also have Niall O’Donnell back for this weekend. The former Donegal player works for LinkedIn and accepted a transfer from Dublin to Chicago at the start of last summer and he has managed his annual leave around big games at home.

niall-odonnell-and-leo-mcloone Niall O'Donnell will be available after missing the Erne Gaels match. Evan Logan / INPHO Evan Logan / INPHO / INPHO

This year, there is an added dimension. Thirty years ago, hurling was revived in the club, encouraged by some exponents who moved to the town through circumstance.

Last weekend, their senior team beat Lisbellaw St Patrick’s of Fermanagh to get through to the Ulster intermediate hurling final, next weekend against Antrim’s Cushendun.

Of the hurlers, Brian MacIntyre, Kevin and John Keeley, Conor Parke and David Horgan straddle both panels. Sean McVeigh is the holder of four senior football championships but finished up with football to solely play hurling this year.

St Eunan’s also had another departure this year. For the first time, they have an outside man with former Fermanagh manager Kieran Donnelly taking the role.

Donnelly has huge experience in this competition, not least his memories of being in charge of Scotstown for the 2018 decider when they were beaten by Gaoth Dobhair.

“Donnelly’s a top man. What a fella,” says Devenney.

“It’s the first time Eunan’s have ever gone outside the club for a manager.

“There’s always been someone there who wanted it and was credible. When Barry Meehan stepped down last year, that was the first time when there wasn’t an obvious successor.

“All those times, there was a Rory Kavanagh to step in, the likes of myself and Eamon O’Boyle, Mickey McGeehin, Brendan Kilcoyne, Charlie Mulgrew. We always had someone ready-made. David McGinley is another.

“This year would have been the first year when it didn’t look like there was anybody ready to go. So the club went and got Kieran who turned out to be very good.”

Time to get the job done.

 

***

Check out the latest episode of The 42′s GAA Weekly podcast here

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel