Ireland captain Dan Sheehan. Ryan Byrne/INPHO

Dan Sheehan's selection at eight is not much of a psychological gambit, just a matter of physics

There was a touch of the Paul O’Donovans to how Sheehan contextualised his new role during Friday’s captain’s run.

THERE WAS ALMOST a ring of Paul O’Donovan to how Dan Sheehan contextualised his role at number eight in Ireland’s team to face South Africa during Friday’s captain’s run.

“I approach it like, ‘I’m not gonna overthink this.’ Eight on my back — just pick the ball up and go, like,” Sheehan explained on the eve of his first Test start in the back row.

“It can’t be that complicated.”

Indeed, France demonstrated as recently as last week that the only way to beat this mighty Springboks side is to get from A to B as fast as you can and hope for the best.

Andy Farrell’s deployment of Sheehan at eight isn’t some psychological gambit, for the likes of which Ireland’s opposition have become so renowned — to put it mildly, both Cameron Hanekom and Siya Kolisi were unmoved by the idea this week. It is, instead, a simple matter of physics, the science in which the Boks remain unparalleled.

dan-sheehan-scores-his-sides-second-try Dan Sheehan scores a try against Argentina. Dan Sheridan / INPHO Dan Sheridan / INPHO / INPHO

The decision is rooted in Ireland’s plain need to get as many of their athletic freaks on the field at the same time, certainly. But it shouldn’t be understated that Rónan Kelleher ranks highly among those very freaks.

The stark reality is that whereas Sheehan’s ball-carrying strengths should be accentuated from eight (it’s inarguable that he’s more explosive than the in-form Cian Prendergast, or indeed Max Deegan or Brian Gleeson in Ireland’s back-row depth chart, and Nick Timoney’s bench impact feels pivotal), he got annihilated in the scrum 12 months ago as the back-to-back world champions inflicted an unprecedented humiliation on Ireland’s set piece.

Leinster teammate Kelleher, a two-time Lions tourist with 57 total Test caps, is bang in form and is, by a significant margin, the best Irish-qualified scrummaging hooker in the country.

The 28-year-old started Ireland’s last two victories over the Boks — during the 2023 World Cup pool stage, and in Durban in the second Test of the 2024 summer tour — and was outstanding on each occasion, as he increasingly tends to be when he takes to the field for his country.

Kelleher, three inches shorter than Sheehan at six foot, is a more complementary scrummaging partner for starting props Andrew Porter and Tadhg Furlong, but he is equally a venomous presence with ball in play, carrying with menace and tackling, somewhat ironically, in the shape of a back row.

And so, that Sheehan has been shifted to eight isn’t merely a deference to the all-court ability of Ireland’s stand-in skipper, but a tip of the cap to Kelleher, too; Farrell demonstrably believes that having both men on the field for as long as possible will maximise Ireland’s chances of toppling the Boks, who arrive in Dublin as 10-point favourites.

ronan-kelleher-is-tackled-by-peceli-yato Rónan Kelleher scores against Fiji. Dan Clohessy / INPHO Dan Clohessy / INPHO / INPHO

The extent to which Sheehan’s selection at the base of the scrum is even a gamble is frankly debatable.

The rugby commentariat — this writer/podcaster included — is sometimes guilty of over-intellectualising fairly rudimentary elements of the sport. And with all due respect to the number eights among The 42′s readership, it is among the easier positions on the field in which to play, to call a spade a spade.

There will be deviations in the detail around Sheehan’s role, of course. He’s not a specialist lineout lifter, not to mind jumper, and only Ireland can know whether a fortnight’s training as a number eight — as well as a few dalliances in past camps, and some reps with Leinster behind the scenes in recent years — will be sufficient for Sheehan to plug in seamlessly. That said, he’s also spent his entire career at the coalface of the lineout for province and country; every meeting, every call, every microscopic moving part has run through him to some extent.

And while Ireland have worked with a retreating scrum in training over the past couple of weeks, the Leinster hooker is not accustomed to scooping the ball up from the back of a mass of men being marched halfway to Bloemfontein in a Test environment, certainly. That said, we are ultimately talking about picking a ball up off the ground in a bit of a scramble — it’s not exactly a proposition that will terrify one of the most talented rugby players on the planet.

There will be adjustments to Sheehan’s positioning in areas such as kick returns and strike plays, but on the other side of the ball, he’ll broadly find himself in the same places as he would as a hooker — two and eight tend are often neighbours in defensive structures.

dan-sheehan Ireland's number eight. Ryan Byrne / INPHO Ryan Byrne / INPHO / INPHO

Appearing almost confused by the degree to which everyone else was complicating it at Friday’s captain’s run, Sheehan said the quiet part out loud in relation to playing number eight: “There aren’t too many niche skillsets or things you have to be aware of.”

The Ireland captain added: “Once the ball is in play, it’s the same thing: it’s just playing rugby.”

Pull like a dog it is, then.

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel