Friday 3 February 2023 Dublin: 10°C
# Espana 82
The Tragedy of Seville: 'Still to this day I have a cracked vertebra and broken teeth'
Ahead of France’s quarter-final meeting with Germany tonight, Patrick Battiston recalls being assaulted by the German goalkeeper 32 years ago.

Soccer - World Cup Spain 82 - Semi Final - West Germany v France EMPICS Sport France's Patrick Battiston is carried off injured after a collision with West Germany goalkeeper Harald Schumacher. EMPICS Sport

FRENCHMAN PATRICK BATTISTON’S place in World Cup folklore is not down to a goal or piece of skill but for being knocked unconscious by German goalkeeper Harald Schumacher in the 1982 World Cup semi-final.

Schumacher’s brutal shoulder charge on Battiston became known in France as the ‘Tragedy of Seville’.

Battiston, now 57 and in charge of Ligue 1 side Bordeaux youth academy, kept his own counsel for a long time over the incident which happened just seven minutes after he had come on as a substitute and saw him lose a couple of teeth, suffer bruised ribs and damaged vertebrae.

With France set to face Germany in the World Cup quarter-finals on this evening — the first meeting at the finals between the two European titans since the 1986 semi-final which the French lost 2-0 — interest has once again been reignited in the dramatic events of that evening in Spain.

Battiston, who appeared in three World Cup finals and was a member of the French side that won the 1984 European championships, said it would be wrong to solely remember the game for what happened to him.

His terrible injuries not only carried a personal cost but also to the team as with only two substitutes allowed in those days Michel Hidalgo was forced to send on his final one.

The importance of fresh legs was brought home when despite leading 3-1 in extra-time the French wilted while the German substitutes engineered a comeback which saw them draw 3-3 and win on penalties.

“Entrenched in our memories is this charge by Schumacher who flattened the little Frenchman,” said Battiston.

“That’s how things are. People talk to me about 1982 often. But it wasn’t only about me.”


Battiston, capped 56 times, says he had already noticed before he came on to replace Bruno Genghini five minutes into the second-half that Schumacher was very pumped up.

“I remember his attitude even when I was sitting on the substitutes bench,” said Battiston, who sticks to the belief that Schumacher’s action was not intentional.

“I observed his behaviour, the way he clashed with Dominique Rocheteau and Didier Six. I thought he was very hyped up, very exciteable. I remarked on this to the other players on the bench.”

Exclusive Six
Nations Analysis

Get Murray Kinsella’s exclusive analysis of Ireland’s Six Nations campaign this spring

Become a Member

Schumacher’s only regret is that he didn’t realise how seriously injured Battiston was and instead of paying attention to him he strolled off, without even a booking.

The referee Charles Corver claimed afterwards he failed to see the incident because he was ‘following the ball’.

However, Battiston was less impressed by Schumacher’s remark that ‘I will pay for the crowns’ at the press conference afterwards when a journalist informed him of the extent of the Frenchman’s injuries.

That was not a very wise remark. It was pretty gauche,” Battiston said. ”Still to this day I have a cracked vertebra and broken teeth.”

Indeed it is Corver not Schumacher who bears the brunt of Battiston’s ire today.

“Recently I tumbled upon by accident images of the match on Arte (a German/Franco financed TV station).

“I paid more attention to what happened on the pitch, after I had been stretchered off, as I had never seen them before.

“The refereeing by Corver who did not whistle for obvious fouls when Germany went behind. That struck me as odd and we have the right to be astonished by that.”

Battiston, little by little, regained some of the memories of that night.

Soccer - World Cup Spain 82 - Semi Final - West Germany v France EMPICS Sport France players gather around the unconscious Battiston. EMPICS Sport

Michel Platini holding his hand in the way someone holds a dying person’s on the way to the hospital and worse the jokey discussion between Corver and Schumacher, both of whom appeared impervious as to the seriousness of what had happened and which revolted the whole of France.

A line was finally drawn under the incident at least on a personal front when Schumacher, shocked by the negative reaction to him back in Germany, asked his agent to organise a press conference between the two of them after the finals even though Battiston had already forgiven him.

“Maybe he did feel guilty, one can draw all sorts of conclusions as to what he did feel. All I know is that Schumacher was someone who wanted to win at all costs and he went way over the top that evening.”

- © AFP, 2014

revistafootball / YouTube

Youthful French momentum could overpower jaded Germans in Rio

‘Barcelona-bound Bravo is my pick of World Cup keepers,’ says Bonner

Your Voice
Readers Comments