Jamie Osborne โ 9: Won every aerial duel, led the team with 17 carries, and made good use of his left boot even down at sea level. Integral to Conor Murrayโs opening try as he picked a great line and popped the ball outside to Robbie Henshaw. Made a try-saving tackle after Jack Crowley was charged down in the first half. Exceptionally polished display on his second cap with his sole error being the misjudgement of a South African exit in the second half.
โ Calvin Nash โ 7: An improved outing on last week. Tidy all-round, defensively sound after a couple of missed tackles in the first half, and kept a few attacks down the right edge ticking over without ever cutting loose.
โ Garry Ringrose โ 7: Like Nash, fell off a few early tackles but there does seem to be a better balance to Irelandโs midfield when he starts. His influence on their defensive shape remains profound and Andy Farrellโs men simply donโt concede many tries when heโs on the field.
โ Robbie Henshaw โ 8: Set the tone among the backs with a kind of maniacal physicality and while he carried into a brick wall all day, he was equally resolute when the ball was moving the other direction. Led the backline โ almost two-fold across the board โ with 11 tackles. Nice support line and neat assist for Murrayโs try.
James Lowe โ 8: Made 10 carries, seven passes, two offloads and two clean breaks โ and this was Lowe on a relatively quiet day. Provided Ireland with momentum at key junctures, including his winning of the five-metre scrum that yielded what proved to be three pivotal points on the stroke of half-time.
Jack Crowley โ 7: Persistently took the ball to the line and mostly got lit the hell up, but not without showing typical touches of class in his distribution. Murrayโs try wouldnโt have happened without his carry and pop inside to Osborne. Mixed bag with kicks from hand under constant pressure โ some excellent decisions and a couple of poor ones. Spotless from the tee after missing three from five last week.
Conor Murray โ 9: Put some respect on his name. What a rugby player.
โ Andrew Porter โ 7: Was unfortunate to concede the scrum penalty he did as Tadhg Furlong came under savage pressure on the tighthead side. Gave away a cheap penalty at the breakdown in his own right which cost Ireland three points. But titanic in the loose, thundering into Boks with the kind of menace that Ireland lacked last Saturday and making 10 tackles to complement his seven carries.
โ Rรณnan Kelleher โ 8: The Leinster hooker had some excellent cameos for Ireland off the bench in the Six Nations but this was him back to his 2021 best. He got through a mountain of work, making 10 carries and 10 tackles, virtually all of which were blood-curdling. Spotless darts in a much-improved Irish lineout and even stole one off the back of a Boksโ throw.
โ Tadhg Furlong โ 5: Decidedly second best in his personal duel with Ox Nche in the scrum. Just a miserable day among countless great ones, and his scrummaging was probably not helped by an apparent hamstring issue either.
Joe McCarthy โ 8: Played like a Bok. Two big turnovers of the South African maul. Powerful line-break in the first half. Beastly at the breakdown when Ireland came under fire.
James Ryan โ 8: Also played like a Bok, delivering one of his most impactful Irish performances in the last 12 months. There was a snarl to Ryan throughout and he made the second most tackles of any Irish player with 12. Stole two South African lineouts just after half-time, although a poor offside on 52 minutes cost his side three points. Went off four minutes later.
Tadhg Beirne โ 7: Did well in the lineout, carried hard albeit for minimal return as was the case with most Irish forwards, and provided some nice link-play when not protecting Irish ball at the breakdown.
Josh van der Flier โ 7: A typically Trojan effort as he chopped down no fewer than 15 Boks. Essentially performed the role that Will Connors was chosen to do ahead of him on three big occasions for Leinster this season.
โ Caelan Doris (captain) โ 8: Would have been a 9 were it not for his yellow card which was both silly and costly โ but Doris otherwise picked up where he left off last week. Saved a try on Irelandโs left edge just after half-time with a key tackle as his side scrambled desperately. Made 57 metres off 14 carries, numbers comparable only to Lowe (57m off 10) and Osborne (56m off 17). Outshone a serious operator in Kwagga Smith for the second test on the spin.
Replacements:
Rob Herring (Kelleher 65โฒ) โ 6: Inherited a lineout that referee Karl Dickson had almost allowed descend to farce but steadied himself to nail his throws, including in the lead-up to Frawleyโs game-winning drop-goal.
Cian Healy (Porter 56โฒ) โ 6: Spent the majority of his 25 minutes at the breakdown where he was needed. Conceded one penalty in the scrum, but sure who didnโt?
โ
Finlay Bealham (Furlong 44โฒ) โ 7: See above, although the penalty awarded against Bealham in the scrum was a nonsensical decision made either by Dickson or his touch judge on that side. Bealham made six impactful tackles to boot.
โ
Ryan Baird (Ryan 56โฒ) โ 6: A quiet cameo by his standards but took two Irish lineouts cleanly.
โ Peter OโMahony (Van der Flier 56โฒ) โ 6: Made a nuisance of himself with five tackles in the final 25 minutes.
โ Caolin Blade (Murray 59โฒ) โ 7: A poor box kick gave South Africa an easy out with 15 minutes to go but Blade was otherwise sharp. He bought a penalty by attacking blind into an offside defender and the precision of his pass for Frawleyโs winning drop-goal shouldnโt be overlooked.
โ Ciarรกn Frawley (Crowley 59โฒ) โ 9: Etched himself into Irish rugby lore with two huge drop-goals just weeks after a couple of similar opportunities went awry in Leinsterโs Champions Cup final defeat to Toulouse. The first, from a South African goal-line drop-out, was an inspired call, dragging Ireland back to within two points at a point in which they seemed capable of creating nothing. The second was impressive not only for its context but for its creation, which was all Frawley as he ran a nice arc and chipped the perfect ball into grass in the South African backfield which eventually yielded Irelandโs final attack from a lineout. No Irish rugby fan old enough to remember will ever forget Frawleyโs heroics in Durban.
โ
Stuart McCloskey (Nash 61โฒ) โ 7: Quiet-ish considering Ireland had virtually no meaningful possession for most of the 20 minutes in which he was on the field. Got the ball rolling for the move which led to the aforementioned lineout in the 79th minute. Earns a bonus point for getting stuck into the Boks when they pleaded for a non-existent obstruction on Cheslin Kolbe after Frawleyโs match-winner.
โThat Leinster failed to score a try and only twice came within obvious striking distance โ through Jamie Heaslip in the first half and Zane Kirchner in the second โ might be cause for concern, but OโConnor felt that was simply the nature of this game.โ
Yep. Thatโs been the nature of a lot of Leinster games this season.
Such a contrast to the quarter final against Cardiff 3 years ago when leinster carved them apart with their backplay. Yesterday they looked so toothless and lateral in attack. OโConnor really is destroying Leinster.
Can joe take charge of leinster for 1 game?
Maybe 2?
Delusional Iโm afraid. No expectation for semi if itโs against Toulon.If Joe Schmidt was leading them iโd give us a good chance.
Iโm sick of reading Leinster fans moaning about MOC. The guy won the league last year, got to a Heineken QF and now this year the champions cup semis. As BOD said on TV yesterday. โHeโs doing allrightโ. You guys are, to quote John Inverdale, lookin at Joe Schmidt era through rose c*n+ed glasses. In case you missed the six nations, Ireland under Joe didnโt play a whole lot of champagne rugby and not many complained. Leinster yesterday were more entertaining than Ireland v France. Also if you take the likes of Sexton, BOD, Necewa, Darcy, Elsom, Leo, Shaggy, Thorn and for most of season, SOB and Healey out of any squad they will struggle to maintain same levels. This Leinster squad is nowhere near as good as Heineken winners but they are doing allright. Leinster fans need to get real and enjoy where they are. Other fans only dream of winning leagues and Euro semis
Just like Munster under McGahan, Leinsterโs problem is how they are doing the basics, not the flash stuff:
> Slow line speed in defence and gaps in close;
> Slow kick chase (& poor organisation)
> Passive defensive rucking
> Limited options in attack (making them easier to defend against)
> Ineffective kicking
Leinster made the breakthrough with high intensity rugby (and not champagne rugby). The minute before half time they showed how effective they could be in defence if they took this approach.
I would prefer to see Kurt McQuilkin back in the set up than Joe S, as Joe is doing quite a good job for Ireland.
There are lots of Irish coaches who could improve Leinster (Bradley would be my preference). But I think Shaun Edwards would probably make the quickest improvement.
Alan.
We may have lost a few of our talismen in the past couple of years, but there is a genuine gripe to be had. We could accept a dip in performance, but weโve all seen how well THESE players are capable of playing. They set their own standards which we came to expect, now theyโve dropped them under MOC and seem to be just making excuses for him. Joeโs rรฉgime was built on honesty, and now thereโs a lack of honesty which the supporters find distasteful.
You guys do understand that you are in a semi final right?
Itโs remarkable that some fans will only be happy when their team reached their unrealistic expectations
Leinster are not as strong as a couple of seasons ago but cโest la vie its the way of things
Itโs your only
job as a supporter to support them.
Then again
Iโve been a connacht supporter for the last few years so maybe I have a different perspectiveโฆ
Donโt get leinster fans wrong weโre delighted to be in the semiโs but you canโt deny were lucky to be here, arguably the easiest pool and we scraped through it scoring the least amount of tries of any of the quarter finalists, weโve lost players such as sexton, BOD, isa etc. so obviously we arenโt going to be as good as we were a few seasons ago but we still expect better than what weโre seeing, yes weโre in a semi final but thereโs also a very realistic chance we wonโt get into the playoffs of the rabo which simply isnโt good enough.
Reg would you accept if Conaught finished bottom of the pro 12 or would you not expect to get better year on year.
I will not accept Leinster playing poorly with no plan for the future and a seriously lack of any attacking ability in the backline.
For all the huha regarding Luke coming back we still canโt score a try with our Backline.
Mark as you said we have lost seriously great players over the past few seasons but is it not the coaches job to one plan for continuity and replace from outside if he needs to.
MOC had spent a vast amount of money replacing those players.
We signed a current aus secondrow
A current springbok to replace Isa
and a top rugby league player to play 13 not to mention The vast amount spent on a temporary deal for a winger who hardly played a game for us.
None of these players can be considered a success do far but whoโs fault is that? Personally I believe itโs the coach Job to get the best from his team.
We have the best academy by a long way in our league if not Europe ( if you consider the schools system that feeds it).
He has not done his job simple as that.
Did Sean oโbrien carry any ball today? If he did he didnโt do enough and that appears to be tacticalโฆ.
Good win, but baths mistakes helped and a hiding awaits in the semi if the performance is similar
Sometimes he can have equal use my having 2 players mark him in defence. Plus he did an awful lot of heavy clearing out today at ruck time.
The face on Heaslip in the top pictureโฆbemused looking to say the least.
What was the plan in the second half? Kick the ball away aimlessly and hope the opposition arenโt good enough to make you pay?
I fear it would take something like Toulon getting an early red card for Leinster to have a realistic chance in the semi
Funny enough john that was the tactic the last time we faced them, everytime we got the ball we kicked it away.
I would argue that Leinster will have a good chance because we are in a semi final with nothing to lose and with our backs to the wall. Sort of like Ireland vs All Blacks. We have a few weeks to learn from our mistakes against Bath also. Tighten up defence etc.
Hereโs for hopingโฆ We can beat Toulon, but not on the back of todayโs performance. No penetration & purpose in attack. Thankfully weโve Madigans boot.
Toulon are favourites, Leinster have to eliminate f*uckups to have a chance
Great win, as all wins at this stage of a major competition usually are, how you do it becomes incidental the win is the only answer.
All points from scrum penalties.itโs a step in the right direction albeit a small one
I think part of the problem lies with the headline. If our coach thinks that we did a โpretty good jobโ then we are in trouble. We played against a really poor pack at home with a big crowd in support and were hanging on at the end. We should have put 20 points on them and anything less was an underperformance.
You canโt expect to win with the old men at half back.
Thereโs no reason whatsoever to play Gopperth as madigan takes all the kicks from hand and tee and we could shore up our midfield with darcy at 12.
We need someone somewhere on the pitch that can defend.
Weโre are the tryโs gone that was such apart of Leinster game ? Same players different coach . Letโs hope they bring back their attacking game for the semi , well done on result today guys