Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
Ireland have long said they can still mix it with the best – now they have the proof
AS SOUTH AFRICA looked to apply the squeeze in a painfully tense end-game, you wondered if Ireland had enough to hold on to their three-point lead and see the game home.
And yet, it was fair to wonder how much it would actually matter if the visitors had managed to nick it. However it was going to end, Ireland had gone a long way toward banishing the ghosts of last November, where South Africa left this stadium having delivered a statement performance which raised concerning questions about the gap between these teams.
That Farrell’s men did indeed hold out and deliver a statement result of their own marks a significant step toward putting them on the right path to attack next year’s World Cup.
A year down the track, Ireland went into this November window talking about restoring belief and closing the gap on the game’s best sides – South Africa, France and New Zealand – who had all recorded commanding wins over Andy Farrell’s men across the previous 12 months.
Delivering a performance tonight was a must. Winning changes the conversation around a team who have underperformed in too many of these fixtures since the 2023 World Cup.
There was nothing new in what Ireland produced here. If anything, they showed there is no great secret to beating the Springboks – it’s just a ferociously hard blueprint to execute.
Rival coaches won’t be poring over the tapes of tonight trying to figure out the secrets. Likewise the formula which saw France beat Rassie Erasmus’ men a week previously. The problem is that making that plan and executing it are two entirely different conversations.
For a start, Ireland had to be accurate, capitalising on their opportunities while, crucially, starving the scrum-loving back-to-back world champions of oxygen by also keeping their own errors down. They had to keep their head above water at the scrum and, perhaps most importantly, they were going to have to absolutely work themselves into the ground. We’re talking the type of effort players speak about when they mention “going to that dark place.” Be an 80-minute team.
And Ireland delivered on everything they had set out to do, putting in their strongest performance for some time.
The first half ended with Farrell’s men 17-10 up, Rónan Kelleher’s try just before the break giving the hosts a cushion they fully deserved. Shortly before that, the Springboks had used the scrum to land their only try of the half and level the scores. A tie game did not feel enough for what Ireland had put into it, but that’s what the Springboks do. You can play all the ball – 60% possession and territory across the opening 40 – but they are the game-leaders in catching up through a handful of moments.
Across the night South Africa did what South Africa did, making their damage through their power game and getting some big wins at the scrum, but here – as in France last week – they offered much less when required to play some ball.
The winners had the look of a team who are extremely well-coached. The visitors had the look of a team who left their leader back in the hotel.
It was Ireland who were full of ideas, scoring three excellent first-half tries and leaving a few more behind them.
You could take your pick of standout performers across the opening period where Ireland put the bulk of their points on the scoreboard.
Joe McCarthy brought his usual bite, as did Stuart McCloskey, who was punchy on both sides of the ball. Robert Balacoune was typically elusive and put himself in the right positions, crossing for two first-half tries and almost landing another in between – losing the ball as he went full-stretch for the tryline.
McCloskey threw a beauty of a pass for one of those Balacoune tries. For the other, Mack Hansen reacted brilliantly to get the ball wide to the Ulster man after his first effort was disrupted. Thinking quick, playing what you see. Proper Andy Farrell rugby.
The ruck speed was excellent, Ireland moving the ball quickly and cleanly and keeping that error count low. Balacoune’s tries were the product of smart, accurate play. Kelleher’s was a sharp idea straight off the training pitch – a tidy lineout coming back on the shortside for the Ireland hooker to finish well. Kelleher is used to starting Ireland games on the bench but he was arguably the pick of the bunch tonight, powerful and purposeful in everything he did.
Farrell cut an animated figure as he addressed his players at half-time. You imagine the message was ‘more of the same’. This Ireland team have chased their fitness and ‘no-talent’ moments as areas that can be their points of difference. Now was the time to show it.
Jamison Gibson-Park kicked intelligently, Sam Prendergast fronted up physically. Robbie Henshaw emptied himself and left the action with a bloodied face. Hugo Keenan spent the 80 minutes of his 50th cap making the right decisions. Ireland’s bench didn’t let the tempo drop. It almost feels cruel to be singling individuals out, such was the consistency of performance across the board.
When Malcom Marx finished a fine South Africa try which showcased all of their power and dynamism shortly before the hour, it arrived after a period where Ireland had played all the rugby.
It threatened to be the turning point. Instead, Ireland went to the well and ensured that would be the last blow they would ship. They now needed to outwork their opponents and keep clear heads. The game grew increasingly scrappy, with much of it being played out in the middle of the pitch.
A busy ruck on 72 minutes saw both sides blink, Dan Sheehan croc rolling before Marco van Staden flung himself as Tadhg Beirne’s head. A yellow for the Ireland captain, and another for the Springboks replacement.
Like France last week, Ireland rode some heavy punishment before the clock hit red. Whereas France didn’t score in the second-half of their win at the Stade de France, here, Ireland’s last score came in the 53rd minute.
That in itself will be something this team can point to when they face into similarly demanding situations over the next year.
And here, it’s worth remembering we’re talking about two sides who had very different lead-ins to this game. While a much-changed Ireland were struggling to click against Fiji last Saturday, South Africa’s big-hitters were nursing the aches from a ferociously intense encounter with France the previous night.
If they are to meet again in 2027, it will be at the business end of a Rugby World Cup and will stand as the most significant moment in this brilliant rivalry’s history. Of course, by that point, Ireland would have already made their own history in the tournament.
Who knows how either of these teams will be shaping up by the time the focus turns to Australia. A year is an awful long time in sport, but what we saw tonight shows this team still have the capability to go toe-to-toe with the game’s best.
They’ve long been telling us they could. Now they have the proof.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
belief Comment Ireland Nations Championship Rugby South Africa