Bruno Fernandes of Manchester United (file pic). Alamy Stock Photo

Is Bruno Fernandes a Mauricio Pochettino player?

The reigning Premier League Player of the Season may not be a seamless fit under the new manager.

FEW, IF ANY, Man United players benefited more from Michael Carrick’s arrival as manager than Bruno Fernandes.

The Portugal international had been playing in a more withdrawn role under Carrick’s predecessor, Ruben Amorim.

The club were in sixth place in January when the club decided to fire Amorim after disagreements with the hierarchy.

So Carrick found the club in a better place than he left them (18th in the table), though there was definite improvement in between – the third-place finish was the club’s best since the 2022-23 campaign under Erik ten Hag.

Fernandes is widely regarded as the club’s greatest signing of the post-Alex Ferguson era, and there is a case that those initial six months under Carrick were his most impressive in a United shirt.

The captain broke the Premier League assists record with 21 and earned both the FWA Player of the Year and Premier League Player of the Season awards.

Had Amorim stayed, it seems unlikely he would have achieved those feats operating in a more defensive midfield role.

Yet United and Fernandes have been less impressive this campaign.

And despite the now-former United manager helping take Fernandes’s career to unprecedented heights, the Portuguese star publicly criticised his boss as soon as the situation went awry.

“It’s a decision from the staff to not press man-to-man and sometimes leave a little space in behind and try to get the ball in the first moment, to wait for them, to give them the ball,” he said after Man United’s Champions League defeat to Como.

“That’s on the manager and on the staff to see it; it’s not on me.” 

He added: “I think sometimes we have to be braver under the pressure, trying to take a risk of getting that press very high and making them uncomfortable – as they did to us.”

Carrick could hardly be blamed for feeling aggrieved at this perceived lack of loyalty during one of his lowest ebbs, and Fernandes was briefly dropped from the team, conceivably because of these inflammatory remarks.

But as is invariably the case, it was the manager rather than the players who lost out in the long run.

A month later, Carrick is unemployed while Fernandes is preparing for a fresh start under Mauricio Pochettino.

The ex-England international is not the only one who has been left unimpressed by the mercurial star.

United legend Roy Keane has previously claimed “talent is not enough” and suggested the midfielder was not “a fighter”.

Amorim once said Fernandes needed to “trust” his teammates more.

Ahead of today’s Premier League clash at Anfield, some people have compared United now with Liverpool when they endured a similar run of sustained underachievement after the glory years of the 1970s and ’80s.

roy-keane-before-the-england-v-croatia-uefa-nations-league-a-group-3-match-at-wembley-stadium-london-england-on-12-november-2026-credit-ian-stephenevery-second-media-credit-every-second-mediaal Roy Keane has been among Fernandes' critics. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

If that is the case, you could argue that Fernandes is the Red Devils’ answer to Steven Gerrard, the one exceptional individual in a team hardly worthy of his talents.

Yet like Gerrard, Fernandes is not flawless.

Similar to the former Liverpool man, he tries to play the Hollywood pass too often. According to WhoScored data released earlier this month, Fernandes has lost possession 175 times in the Premier League this season, which is more than any other player.

He is often criticised too as more of an individual than a team player – a perception the Carrick criticism played into.

Work off the ball is something Fernandes is hardly renowned for either. Perhaps he gets licence to avoid these duties owing to his obvious creative strengths.

But when the team is struggling, Fernandes can look like a luxury player and not worth the star treatment he is afforded.

It epitomises an issue with the culture at United, seemingly — too many players are reluctant to graft for the greater cause and perform at the maximum only sporadically.

The Red Devils, for example, are third-bottom in the distance-covered charts so far this season.

By contrast, when it comes to Pochettino’s managerial peak, you think of the intensity and relentless running of his Tottenham sides.

United and Fernandes, therefore, are hardly a seamless fit for the 54-year-old manager, who counts Marcelo Bielsa (the coach he played under as a youngster in the early 1990s at Newell’s Old Boys) among his biggest influences.

ruben-amorim-head-coach-of-ac-milan-looks-on-during-the-uefa-europa-league-202627-league-phase-md4-match-between-ac-milan-and-ferencvarosi-tc-at-stadio-san-siro-on-november-5-2026-in-milan-italy Ruben Amorim was criticised for not playing Fernandes in his favoured attacking midfield role. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

One of the Red Devils’ major problems is that whenever an ideologue coach gets appointed in recent times – Ten Hag and Amorim are the obvious examples – you get the sense that they have been asked to adapt to the demands of the club rather than the other way around.

Ten Hag admitted that at Old Trafford, it simply wasn’t possible to play the style that established him as a top coach at Ajax.

One of the reported arguments between the club’s board and Amorim was the latter’s refusal to dispense with his favoured three-at-the-back system.

An elite club tends to thrive when it is revolving around one central authority figure, yet at United, it feels like there are often multiple personalities vying for complete control.

By contrast, think of Pep Guardiola at City. One of his first acts was to dispense with goalkeeper Joe Hart – one of the club’s biggest and most popular players at the time – not because the England star was underperforming, but because he didn’t suit his system.

Similarly, Jürgen Klopp at Liverpool arrived in October 2015, three months after they had paid £32.5 million (€38.81 million) for Christian Benteke. The Belgian international saw his minutes reduced and was sold at the start of the following season despite the big money invested in him.

In his early years at the club, Alex Ferguson moved on players of the calibre of Paul McGrath and Norman Whiteside, and he continued to do so throughout his reign, with David Beckham and Keane among those to depart Old Trafford in acrimonious circumstances.

manchester-uniteds-david-beckham-with-manager-sir-alex-ferguson-after-signing-a-new-contract Alex Ferguson sold David Beckham among other big calls during his tenure. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

Big managers make big calls.

Pochettino, therefore, must not compromise his vision.

The manager has backed Fernandes publicly, but he may be having different thoughts in private.

The player has admitted coming close to leaving the club in the past, and as recently as last year, suggested United wanted him to accept a big-money move to Saudi Arabian side Al-Hilal.

Fernandes is now in his eighth season at Old Trafford, and regardless of his individual brilliance, the team have been a mess for much of that period.

He will also be 33 next September and increasingly ill-suited to the physicality of English football.

Many will see him as one of the best players never to win a Premier League title (assuming United don’t improve promptly).

Yet veteran stars often decline quite rapidly – Mo Salah went from Premier League Player of the Season to surplus to requirements at Liverpool in less than 12 months.

And you wonder whether at this point, a clean break might be best for the player and club.

If Pochettino wants to resurrect United and turn them into title contenders, sacrificing a big player could be the catalyst.

Youth, energy and innovative ideas are needed to rejuvenate this sleeping giant, not reliance on the same old faces that have failed for too long.

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel