Mauricio Pochettino turned Spurs into Champions League regulars during his five years at the club. Alamy Stock Photo

Pochettino oversaw one of the great achievements of the Premier League era. Can he do it again?

It is 10 years since the Argentine manager’s best moment as a manager.

MAURICIO POCHETTINO OFFICIALLY begins life as Manchester United manager today, and his task is a daunting one.

It will certainly be harder than beating Haiti, who the US overcame 8-0 on aggregate in the coach’s last two games as an international manager, wrapping up in the early hours of this morning Irish time before the sterner test of travelling to face Liverpool at Anfield for the 4.30pm game this Sunday.

Of the seven previous permanent managers who have coached the club in the post-Alex Ferguson era, all have emerged from a chastening experience with diminished reputations.

The primary reason Pochettino was chosen over other candidates – who reportedly included Antonio Conte, Eddie Howe, Julian Nagelsmann and Cesc Fàbregas – was for the job he did at Tottenham.

Everything since has felt like a stopgap, especially his most recent job with the USA, where barring a disastrous group-stage exit at this summer’s World Cup, he was always likely to be judged favourably.

Early in his career, the Argentine previously impressed in coaching stints at Espanyol and Southampton – guiding the latter to their highest-ever Premier League points tally at the time.

But it was at Spurs where Pochettino’s stock skyrocketed.

The situation is considerably different to United now, of course. Pochettino inherited a side that had finished sixth the previous season, as opposed to one that is languishing in 18th place.

tottenham-hotspurs-caretaker-manager-tim-sherwood-calls-out-to-his-players-as-he-watches-his-team-play-against-west-ham-united-during-their-english-league-cup-quarterfinal-soccer-match-at-white-hart Pochettino succeeded Tim Sherwood as Tottenham manager. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

Yet Tottenham still looked a million miles off the top sides – the 2013-14 season had included 6-0 and 5-1 defeats to Man City, and 4-0 losses to Chelsea and Liverpool, with André Villas-Boas and subsequent caretaker boss Tim Sherwood failing to have the desired effect.

It’s fair to say Pochettino had some good raw materials to work with. By the time he arrived at White Hart Lane, Kyle Walker, Danny Rose, Jan Vertonghen, Hugo Lloris, Mousa Dembélé, Christian Eriksen and Harry Kane were already in situ, though the latter had yet to establish himself as a first-team regular.

But the manager made a series of astute decisions to transform the club.

They had experienced just one season in the Champions League before his arrival – 2010-11, when a Gareth Bale-inspired side reached the quarter-finals.

But under Pochettino, they would reach Europe’s premier club competition four seasons in a row, including a memorable run to the final in 2019.

Dele Alli, Eric Dier and Ben Davies (still a Tottenham player now) were among the important early recruitments at Spurs.

Toby Alderweireld, Son Heung-min and Kieran Trippier arrived the following season.

Victor Wanyama and Moussa Sissoko later added steel to the midfield.

Consequently, Tottenham gradually improved under the exciting young manager.

tottenham-players-celebrate-after-scoring-their-third-goal-during-the-champions-league-semifinal-second-leg-soccer-match-between-ajax-and-tottenham-hotspur-at-the-johan-cruyff-arena-in-amsterdam-neth Tottenham players celebrate after scoring their third goal during the Champions League semi-final second leg against Ajax. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

Some people might suggest 2018-19, when they reached the Champions League final, was their peak, or 2015-16, when they threatened to disrupt Leicester City’s title charge.

But really, it is the 2016-17 season that should be remembered as the high point for Pochettino at Spurs.

It was the North Londoners’ best-ever Premier League finish (second) and points tally (86).

It was achieved despite the club spending frugally compared with their rivals, owing to the money they were putting into their new stadium.

They had to play at Wembley for an extended period, and Lloris has hinted the decision to leave White Hart Lane cost them a Premier League title.

In some ways, this financial predicament was turned into a positive – would they have placed faith in youngsters like Kane and Alli if they had more money to spend on big-name players?

But Pochettino still deserves credit for helping to turn these high-potential footballers into superstars (even if Alli held that status all too briefly).

What Tottenham were doing around this period was overshadowed to a degree by the Leicester triumph, but it was similarly impressive.

They still finished runners-up in 2017, of course, and the biggest criticism of Pochettino’s tenure at Spurs is that he never won a trophy.

chelsea-captain-john-terry-right-and-gary-cahill-raise-the-trophy-with-manager-antonio-conte-at-far-left-after-they-won-the-league-following-the-english-premier-league-soccer-match-between-chelse Pochettino has suggested Chelsea should be stripped of the 2017 Premier League title. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

But should they have been awarded the 2016-17 title? The Argentine believes so.

Last March, Chelsea were fined £10.75 million (€12.91 million) after being charged by the Premier League for historical breaches of competition rules.

The club’s owners, Todd Boehly and Clearlake Capital, self-reported 74 breaches of Football Association rules after purchasing the club in 2022.

The Blues admitted making £47 million (€56.43 million) in secret payments to unregistered agents and third parties involving transfers between 2011 and 2018.

Many people, including Pochettino, felt the punishment was unduly lenient.

“We should win one title, one Premier League,” he told reporters. “We should have been awarded it.

“[Chelsea] were punished, they admitted, so that’s it? The title should be for the team that was second.

“It’s true that we didn’t compete with the same rules. It’s completely fair to say that we didn’t compete before the start of the season with the same card.”

But whether you agree that Spurs should have been awarded the title, given the limitations Pochettino was working with, picking up 86 points, which would have been enough to win the top flight in many previous seasons, is one of the great Premier League achievements.

As journalist Simon Kuper and economist Stefan Szymanski explained in their landmark book Soccernomics, a football club’s spending on player wages is the most reliable indicator of league position. Tottenham were a rare example of a club dramatically overachieving in this regard.

london-uk-12th-nov-2026-manchester-united-sack-another-manager-michael-carrick-to-leave-the-club-file-photo-manchester-united-owner-sir-jim-ratcliffe-ceo-omar-berrada-and-director-of Manchester United owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe, CEO Omar Berrada and Director Of Football Jason Wilcox. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

Man United are not as disadvantaged by comparison. The Red Devils had the second-biggest net spend of Premier League teams in the last five years. The club also have the fourth-biggest wage bill this season, behind only Man City, Liverpool and Arsenal.

But it is now 10 years since what is still probably Pochettino’s finest moment as a manager, and transforming the Red Devils’ fortunes is arguably an even bigger challenge compared to what he faced at Tottenham in 2014.

Even though he won a Ligue 1 title and Coupe de France, his spell at PSG lasted only 18 months as he failed to deliver an elusive Champions League trophy.

Chelsea was similarly underwhelming, and he departed after less than a year in charge, after guiding the Blues to a sixth-place finish. But internal disagreements with figures at the club were seemingly as much of a factor as results in this abrupt exit – The Guardian quoted one source describing his training methods as “antiquated” while Pochettino reportedly wanted more control over signings.

file-photo-dated-26-01-2025-of-daniel-levy-tottenham-have-announced-the-departure-of-chief-executive-daniel-levy-issue-date-thursday-september-4-2025 Pochettino didn't always see eye to eye with Tottenham's then-chief executive Daniel Levy. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

Boardroom tension was also one of the reasons for his Tottenham exit, as Pochettino grew frustrated with the club’s reluctance to back him in the transfer market.

Spurs made no major signings in 2018-19 when they reached the Champions League final, and were unwilling to overhaul a squad that was clearly in decline. Pochettino’s complaints have aged well, given how far the North Londoners have fallen in subsequent years. Had they listened to him originally, he had the potential to become Tottenham’s equivalent to Mikel Arteta. When they met in the 2019 Champions League final, it felt like Spurs and Liverpool were at similar stages of development, but the two clubs went in opposite directions thereafter.

But given his issues behind the scenes at both Chelsea and Tottenham, it seems logical to ask whether he will fare any better with the likes of Jim Ratcliffe, Jason Wilcox and Omar Berrada, who haven’t exactly endeared themselves to past Man United managers.

Another potential issue is Pochettino’s style.

The Argentine tends to favour players capable of relentless running and high intensity – in other words, traits you would not associate with the current Man United team, to put it mildly. Could this dichotomy be his equivalent of Ruben Amorim stubbornly insisting on always playing three at the back?

At Spurs, he was ruthless in casting aside experienced, high-profile players – the likes of Paulinho, Roberto Soldado, Emmanuel Adebayor, Andros Townsend and Vlad Chiricheș didn’t last long after his arrival.

It paved the way for a squad of largely young, malleable players open to new ideas who bought into the Pochettino philosophy.

coach-of-psg-mauricio-pochettino-talks-to-lionel-messi-of-psg-before-he-enters-the-pitch-during-the-french-championship-ligue-1-football-match-between-stade-de-reims-and-paris-saint-germain-on-august Mauricio Pochettino talks to Lionel Messi of PSG before he enters the pitch during ta Ligue 1 match against Stade de Reims. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

The ex-Argentina international has not been as successful in repeating this formula elsewhere. At PSG in particular, having a front trio of Lionel Messi, Neymar and Kylian Mbappé seemed antithetical to his approach, and so it’s no surprise he struggled to impose his personality on the club.

To what extent United are willing to trust the 54-year-old will likely determine whether the project succeeds.

Erik ten Hag and Amorim established themselves as elite managers partly because they were considered ideologues. But both struggled to reverse the culture at United – a problematic environment that has been reflected in results in the 13-plus years since Alex Ferguson’s departure. 

A looser approach under Michael Carrick initially worked well, but bad habits have recurred this season, plunging the Red Devils into yet another crisis.

It feels like another radical solution is required. A manager who can dominate the club through sheer willpower and force of personality in a manner that all the greats – Ferguson, Jürgen Klopp and Pep Guardiola included – usually do. But whether Pochettino and the club’s hierarchy have the patience and stomach for this painstaking process remains uncertain.

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel