Poll: Should this have been an Irish penalty?

Keith Earls was prevented from claiming a late try by Vincent Debaty in Ireland’s draw with France.

IRELAND HAD TO settle for a 13-13 draw with France this evening but with minutes on the clock were close to grabbing what would have been a match-winning try.

Eoin Reddan kicked into the corner and Keith Earls was barged out of play by Vincent Debaty as he attempted to get the vital touch.

Referee Steve Walsh went to the TMO and after taking his time to look at all the angles, the decision was a 22 droupout.

YouTube credit: RBS6Nations

“It fits into the law of shoulder-to-shoulder,” argued RTE panellist George Hook while Declan Kidney said:

That’s one of these decisions. I think the TMO was asked about try or no try – obviously it wasn’t. But ‘foul play, or not’, that seemed the to be taken out of his hands.”

What are they
really like?

Rare insights on sport's biggest names from the writers who know them best. Listen to Behind the Lines podcast.

Become a Member

What do you think… should Ireland have been awarded a penalty?

Poll Results:

No (600)
Yes (293)

6 Nations: Halfpenny boot shines through messy Welsh win

Champions: Italy loss seals 6 Nations crown for Ireland women

About the author:

Ben Blake

Read next: