This site uses cookies to improve your experience and to provide services and advertising. By continuing to browse, you agree to the use of cookies described in our Cookies Policy. You may change your settings at any time but this may impact on the functionality of the site. To learn more see our Cookies Policy.
Dublin: 7 °C Saturday 19 October, 2019

Officiating unfair to Italy, claims Conor O'Shea

The hosts were beaten by Wales in Rome.

The former RTÉ panelist was frustrated by the ref's decisions.
The former RTÉ panelist was frustrated by the ref's decisions.
Image: Matteo Ciambelli/INPHO

ITALY COACH Conor O’Shea invited media to “watch the first two minutes” of his side’s 33-7 Six Nations defeat to Wales amid claims the hosts received unfair officiating.

On his Six Nations coaching debut O’Shea saw a determined Italy take a 7-3 lead into the dressing room at half-time.

But hopes of causing another major upset less than two months after an historic 20-18 win over South Africa were scuppered by ill discipline at the start of the second half that allowed Leigh Halfpenny to hit three penalties in succession.

When prop Andrea Lovotti was ordered to take a seat in the sin bin on the hour, Italy were a man down and Wales capitalised to run in three late tries.

In total Italy were awarded just five penalties to Wales’s 15, a statistic that left O’Shea puzzled after the game.

While he refused to point the finger directly at Irish referee JP Doyle, O’Shea claimed Wales were given the benefit of the doubt more than their fair share.

“The penalties against us were probably all justified,” said O’Shea. “It’s only the five penalties against them I can’t understand.”

Pushed to elaborate on his claims, the former Harlequins handler added: “Watch the first two minutes of the match, and the scene is set.”

O’Shea will now take issue with his players to address their ill discipline. Otherwise, he suggested, Italy will suffer from the perception match officials have of them.

“We want to change the perception because we need to make sure that both red and blue (shirts) are being looked at in exactly the same way,” he added.

“And we have to make sure we change the perception of people who look at us so that we’re officiated on a level playing field.”

Asked how Italy could improve those prospects, he said: “We have to be whiter than white, and not get frustrated when decisions go against you …it’s just one of the many things we have to get our heads around.”

Sergio Parisse with JP Doyle Source: Matteo Ciambelli/INPHO

Italy looked set to push Wales all the way but the hosts were a different side in the second half.

Halfpenny hit three penalties in succession and Wales were 12-7 to the good before the hour.

He said: “I’m not going to comment about the referee or Conor’s comments. I thought our team was disciplined, we competed when we needed to.”

Italy captain Sergio Parisse admitted: “Two of the penalties were my fault.”

But he also levelled allegations at Doyle, claiming the English referee did not take Wales to task early in the game.

“We dominated them at the breakdown and they were seriously slowing the game down without being sanctioned,” said Parisse after claiming his 122nd cap.

Lovotti’s walk to the sinbin on the hour dented increasingly unlikely chances of an Italy fightback.

Wales got their first try just a minute later with a great move that saw Scott Williams collect possession and take out two players with a feint to set up Jonathan Davies for his 13th try in 60 matches.

Halfpenny hit the conversion to give Wales a 19-7 lead on 62 minutes but further tries from Liam Williams and George North, Halfpenny converting both, hammered home Wales’ second-half superiority.

Asked to comment on O’Shea’s claims, interim Wales coach Rob Howley, in charge while head coach Warren Gatland is on duty with the British and Irish Lions, was evasive.

© AFP 2017

Subscribe to The42 Rugby Show podcast here:

‘Apart from missing family, there’s no real desire to move back home’

Wales late show stuns valiant Italy in Rome

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article

About the author:


Read next: