Darragh Beirne celebrates his goal for Mayo in the All-Ireland final. Ryan Byrne/INPHO

Four points for a goal in Gaelic football? The timing may not be quite right

Kevin McStay’s Expert Advisory Group is sending the proposal to Central Council.

FOR THOSE THAT suffer from rule change fatigue, they might be glad to learn that the recent experimentations appear to be fizzling out.

The Expert Advisory Group, led by Kevin McStay, have had a look at their sandbox games in the Ryan Cup, weighed up what’s workable, and clearly feel that a goal should be worth four points.

Others, such as a limit on consecutive handpasses, have had numerous trials at this stage and has never had anything but an uneasy reception.

Banning fist-passed points is already something that would force players into another process of recycling the ball. Somehow, the idea of punching a ball over the bar has been characterised as something that lacks skill, but there are many would dispute that.

It will be the four-point goal however that will travel through the hoops of administration. First, to the GAA Management Committee, and then Central Council. Members of Central Council will be briefed early this week before their meeting at the weekend.

kevin-mcstay Kevin McStay. Bryan Keane Bryan Keane

While Gaelic football has had many tweaks and changes over the past two years, some of them in-season, this feels a little bit too big to be waved through.

This is just our hunch. It’s only a hunch. Don’t go laying any money on it, but it will not get through.

Change has been good for Gaelic football. But the majority of delegates will feel that there has to be a time given over to let the game settle and evolve without another rule change that would have significant consequences.

The two-point arc (and there should be a rubber-stamping exercise that this line continues to the end lines) has revolutionised the approach of county teams.

This then filters down to the club game where club teams in the provincial championships are now – in late 2026 – playing the type of sophisticated game well ahead of when county teams were trying to get to grips with things in early 2025 .

david-clifford-scores-his-sides-first-goal-of-the-match-despite-david-byrne David Clifford scores on the rebound from his penalty against Dublin. James Crombie / INPHO James Crombie / INPHO / INPHO

With teams now carrying threat of two-point shooters, and six players restricted to staying in the other side of the pitch, it has become a game that favours attackers.

The effect of having an accurate shooter out the field leaves teams having to push out, thereby leaving more space inside for the goal hunters.

All of this has meant that championship scores have jumped from 34 in 2024, to 46 a year later, and 48 points per game in the season gone by.

Goals have also increased. 2.1 to 2.8 per game in the championship from 2025 to 2026.

Before all that evidence was compiled, Kerry attacker Paul Geaney was looking forward to the summer of football while speaking at the Munster championship launch last April, talking about the two-point arc.

“I love it. It’s unreal and I hope the goals don’t suffer as a result of it down the line. I would have said as well from the start that they should have left the goals at four,” said Geaney.

“You can see it already. Goal numbers are going down and two pointers are going up. You would be concerned that in a couple of years’ time it’s basketball where you only take two point shots. The stats guys are already telling all their teams, don’t bother. The probabilities just doesn’t line up. So you have to reward it by bringing it maybe up to four.

“I have a reservation about it that way, but I love seeing the skill of long distance. At the moment it’s okay, there’s a nice balance. Again it keeps games live until late, so there’s that aspect as well. Seeing the outside of the boot from Ruaidhri Fallon or from Tom (O’Sullivan) or a loop shot from like David Clifford. Hopefully it stays with the play for the most part.”

Right now, goals are more ‘on’ than they have in many years.

Does it make sense, then, that a brace of two-pointers can not only wipe out a goal but top it?

The effect of a goal still electrifies a game. Darragh Beirne’s goal in the All-Ireland final put Mayo four points in from of Kerry. But it also changed the entire feeling inside a stadium.

As the two-point shot becomes more embedded in the game, the concession of a goal will feel less and less insurmountable.

However, the sight of a goal is one of the most attractive skills in the game, a contest between goalkeeper and the attacker with the opportunity.

The moment it starts to feel a little less than that, then you can expect to see the four-point goal.

But it’s not time. Not just yet.  

 

***

Check out the latest episode of The 42′s GAA Weekly podcast here

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel