Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
'Is that not match-fixing?' - Erasmus launches stinging tirade
SPRINGBOKS BOSS RASSIE Erasmus launched a stinging questioning of some of the match officials’ decisions during his side’s loss against France, while predicting that Ireland out-half Sam Prendergast will escape a suspension after being cited.
Erasmus went as far as to question whether “match-fixing” and “manipulation of the game” are involved in incidents of foul play not being picked up live during matches.
The Springboks boss also said that Tadhg Furlong not being suspended recently for an alleged groin grab on Gavin Coombes during Leinster’s clash with Munster had “hurt” South African rugby.
As he predicted that Prendergast will not be suspended for what Erasmus called a “terrible” hip drop tackle against Fiji, and will therefore play against his side this weekend, the South Africa head coach claimed that match officials had missed 17 knee drop tackles in their loss in Paris on Friday night.
Prendergast is set to be cited for a hip drop tackle against Fiji on Saturday, putting his involvement for Ireland against the Springboks in doubt, but Erasmus believes he won’t be banned.
“I am going to say the right words now,” said Erasmus when asked about the possibility of Prendergast missing the game.
“We are in the Northern Hemisphere. I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play.”
Erasmus was asked what he meant by ‘technicality’ and launched into an extended and impassioned explanation of how he felt knee drop tackles were missed in South Africa’s loss to France.
“It’s Monday, it’s now in the papers,” said Erasmus of the Prendergast case, which has yet to be publicly confirmed by the Nations Championship.
“Was it within the period, the 12-hour period? Who cited him? When was it cited?
“When Jasper got cited [for his red card against France], it was six hours after the game.
“We got the papers. Northern Hemisphere, he’ll probably get cited [suspended] for two or three weeks, so he can’t play in the next two games and then he’ll probably be available. We’ll get that release.
“My experience from when we’re here it’s… I’m not 100% sure how it works. I’m not a legal guy. I don’t have the right to say anything on it.
“I don’t have a pleasant experience here from going through Lood de Jager, Jan-Hendrik Wessels, Franco Mostert when we were here, all the things. And then it never seems to go away. I’m not saying anybody’s doing anything wrong. I’m just not expecting him to get… I think he’ll play on Saturday.
“My experience is… like Tadhg [Furlong] got free for the same thing that Jan-Hendrik did. I don’t want to go into details there because I’m not a legal person, but from a South African point of view, that hurt, that we felt it’s more or less the same situation and Jan-Hendrik got nine weeks, the other guy got free.
“I think the hip drop tackle was terrible, in my opinion, compared to where we were at the World Rugby meetings and all coaches were there except the Irish coach and the French coach. We had like three hours discussion about the hip drop tackle, hip drop tackle and, you know, it’s weird.
“It’s difficult to understand when the TMO sits there and he sees that. And it was something we discussed at the World Rugby meeting, and the examples of how it is was shown over and over, and we all had input.
“Somebody sees that and he decides there’s nothing wrong with that. Then you wonder, but all of us coaches sit there and all of us gave input. So when you see that, and you decide that there’s nothing wrong with that, what do the other coaches or the other people, what did Jake [White, Fiji head coach] feel? What did that guy that got injured and got carried off?
“We all thought it’s an immediate red card. Everybody watched the game live because that’s exactly what they said the hip drop tackle is.
“I swear I’m not moaning. I’m just trying to give you a perspective of somebody who comes and play, for example, in France or in Ireland.”
Erasmus then proceeded to turn to what he saw as repeated knee drop tackles by France against his team.
Referees were recently asked to clamp down on knee drop tackles, where the defender goes to their knee before making contact with the ball-carrier.
“The other thing that was brought up at the World Rugby meeting was knee-drop tackles. Now, I give you my word, there were 16 against us against France. 16 knee drop tackles.
“And again, I’m not saying the referee didn’t see it or the referee didn’t judge it wrong, but I don’t understand the narrative that people want the TMO to stay out.
“Because for me, and I’m gonna say it as it is, for me, if you want a TMO to stay out, and two things happen. Firstly, safety, which everybody in the Northern Hemisphere and South Africa and the world are promoting and saying, listen here, the safety of the game is a priority. Head knocks, concussions, people’s well-being must be protected.
“And then the second one is, fair, the right team must win. So if you see something where it should be penalised or yellow carded and you ignore it, but you see it and you ignore it, the conclusion must be you’re influencing the result of the team or you’re letting somebody get hurt, if you see it.
“If you didn’t see it, oh surely it’s a mistake, somebody made it. And I don’t understand why we had that meetings and then in our game, I’m honestly now saying to you, there were 17.
“Let’s say 11 of those was, I thought, at least a penalty and three I thought is at least yellow card. And not one was sanctioned. And not one was showed out or cited.
“And I’ll send you the playlist, but I’ll get into trouble, so I can’t send the playlist to anybody and we can only send five clips to World Rugby. So we’ll probably query it, but the answer will be, ‘Yes, it was a mistake.’ They should have penalised that.
“Same with the Prendergast thing, you know, so who am I to judge that? My gut feeling is he’ll play on Saturday.”
As he continued, Erasmus said that France scrum-half Maxime Lucu had only been in the sin bin for seven minutes on Friday night, despite a sin-bin period being 10 minutes.
“So that’s fine that happened, but then there’s 17 knee-drop tackles and the TMO doesn’t come in once,” said Erasmus.
“I’m not saying he’s wrong, I’m saying if he didn’t see it, it must be a technology problem. If he saw it and decided not to act on it, is that not match-fixing? Is that not interfering with the outcome of a game if you see this injury that happened there, a knee-drop tackle happened there, and it’s been decided that knee drop tackles are out.
“On numerous times, we mentioned to the referee ‘we think there’s (been) a knee drop tackle’.
“Now, I’m saying to you, my feeling is knee drop tackles is out. They happened 17 in our games. Not one was penalised even.
“And if the TMO didn’t see it, maybe then technology must be better. If he saw it and he ignored it, what does that boil down to?
“Manipulation of the game or the result or injured players getting injured. So all I’m asking, don’t take TMOs out and discourage them to get involved. Then the wrong team will win and players will get injured. That’s all I’m saying.”
It was pointed out to Erasmus that this was a serious intimation he was making, with Erasmus stressing that he wasn’t accusing anyone of anything.
“It’s not an accusation, it’s not an accusation,” said Erasmus.
He was asked if he believes the Springboks are treated unfairly, despite being back-to-back world champions.
“No, not us, not us,” said Erasmus.
“I think Jake White’s team, they lost their hooker [sic] with a hip drop tackle that was three weeks ago at the World Rugby meeting decided, over and over with clips, this is a hip drop tackle.
“Now all of us who were there saw it, that it’s exactly what they explained to us there. Now the TMO sees it. Now, if he didn’t see it, that’s a different thing.
“But if he saw it and he decided, ‘Well, I’m gonna ignore it.’ What would you make of it?
“OK, if he missed it, different story. But if he saw it and he ignored it, what is that?
“Go and have a look at the TV footage. Not at that other camera angles and stuff which we have. Go and look at the TV footage and look at the player going to the referee and saying to him. It couldn’t have been missed.”
The 42 has contacted World Rugby for comment.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Hip drop tackles knee drop tackles Match Officials Rassie Erasmus Rugby