i tonya

How a rom-com writer ended up making a film about one of sport's most infamous scandals

The unforgettable story of Tonya Harding and Nancy Kerrigan.

I, Tonya Premiere - Los Angeles SIPA USA / PA Images Tonya Harding and Margot Robbie at the Los Angeles premiere of I, Tonya. SIPA USA / PA Images / PA Images

THE LIFE OF a screenwriter in Hollywood is a thankless job.

It is days filled with coming up with stories that will satisfy the tastes of a mass audience, which eventually get poked and prodded by everyone from executives to directors to stars. When a movie you wrote finally shows up on the big screen, it looks nothing like what was originally written — if it makes it on screen at all.

Steven Rogers has spent decades working as a scribe in the studio system, and though his name is on recognisable titles such as Hope Floats, Stepmom, and Kate & Leopold, he’s also got the scars of a career Hollywood screenwriter.

“Starting out I didn’t know anything,” Rogers said, sitting in a hotel room at the Crosby Hotel in Lower Manhattan.

“I didn’t even know what I didn’t know. I didn’t know how to protect myself.”

Rogers was in his twenties when his first-ever screenplay was made, Hope Floats, the 1998 romance movie starring Sandra Bullock and Harry Connick Jr that has since become a TV staple. That same year his second script hit cinemas, Stepmom, a tearjerker starring Julia Roberts and Susan Sarandon that also became a TV classic.

Rogers didn’t know it yet, but he was instantly pigeon-holed as the “romance” guy in Hollywood. If a romantic drama or comedy needed to be written, Rogers was the guy. It led to years of his phone ringing off the hook matched by years of barely getting a call back from his agent. As Rogers put it: “I’ve been flavour of the month and I’ve been told I’m cold and they can’t do anything with me.”

When Rogers hit a cold spell he would just block everything out and come up with a new script. But after the horrific reviews for the 2015 holiday comedy he penned, Love the Coopers, he knew he couldn’t go on much longer working like this.

“I had to reinvent myself,” he said. “Even if I had wanted to go back to the studio system, the rom-coms and romantic dramas, they were rapidly not making those anymore. I had to go in a different direction.”

It was around this time when Rogers realised how he could start over after watching the ESPN 30 for 30 documentary, The Price of Gold. Sitting with his niece, they were glued to the screen watching the story of one of sport’s most infamous people, Tonya Harding.

A brilliant figure skater with Olympic hopes, in 1994 she became one of the most known names and faces on the planet when her ex-husband, Jeff Gillooly, organised (with his dimwitted friends) an attack on Harding’s fellow US figure skater, Nancy Kerrigan. Footage of Kerrigan screaming “Why, why, why?” as she clutched her leg was the main story on the 24-hour news channels and evening news for weeks. And Harding became the target of every news outlet trying to figure out if she was involved in the attack.

New Trailer Buzz / YouTube

“The perception of truth, memory, family, media, and class, I thought that all would be interesting to write about,” Rogers said looking back on watching Price of Gold.

Rogers looked up Tonya Harding’s website and called the contact number on it. The phone number went to the front desk of a Motel 6. Rogers was hooked.

Rogers broke every screenwriting rule he knew to write I, Tonya which is due to be released in Irish cinemas in February. The movie looks at the life of Harding, played by Margot Robbie, from the perspectives of the disgraced figure skater, ex-husband Jeff Gillooly (Sebastian Stan), and Harding’s mother (among others). It’s hilarious and horrific at the same time. Rogers weaves a tale of Harding’s rise in figure skating, her abusive upbringing by her mother (Alison Janney), and her abusive relationship and eventual marriage to Gillooly. (Gillooly claims most of the physical assaults Harding says happened didn’t.)

And that’s the core of Rogers’ story, brought to life by director Craig Gillespie. He lets all his characters have the floor to set the record straight. It’s up to the audience to decide if any of it is true.

The movie also delves deep into the Kerrigan attack and aftermath. Again, it’s up to you to believe who is telling the truth.

10- Jeff Gillooly (Sebastian Stan), Tonya Harding (Margot Robbie) and Diane Rawlinson (Julianne Nicholson) in I, TONYA, courtesy of NEON and 30WEST NEON / 30WEST Jeff Gillooly (Stan), Tonya Harding (Robbie) and Diane Rawlinson (Julianne Nicholson). NEON / 30WEST / 30WEST

The reason why Rogers’ script is such a knockout is because of the work he put in before typing a single word — all done on spec. After realising Harding was not at the Motel 6, Rogers continued to try to track her down. His search led him to Texas where he thought he had found Harding’s manager. It turned out the person wasn’t, but she was a friend of Harding’s and because the woman was familiar with Rogers’ writing credits, she connected him with Harding.

After a few months of searching, Rogers was finally face-to-face with Harding. The two hit it off and agreed to have Rogers sit with her over two days and interview her about her life. But first Rogers had to get her life rights. It took some time, mostly because Rogers said Harding didn’t want to pay for a lawyer so she got her ex-manager to do the negotiation pro bono.

Rogers said Harding was open to talk about everything. “She did say to me at one point, ‘Now, do I have any say in this?’” Rogers said. “And I said, ‘No, I’m going to tell everybody’s point of view.’ She was okay with that.”

UPI 20171128 UPI / PA Images Rogers: CV included rom-com hits Hope Floats, Stepmom, and Kate & Leopold. UPI / PA Images / PA Images

With the Harding interviews done he went out to find Jeff Gillooly.

After getting out of prison in 1995 on a racketeering charge for masterminding the Kerrigan attack, Gillooly tried to move on with this life. He shaved his trademark moustache and changed his last name to Stone. But it wasn’t a total disappearing act because he moved back to his hometown. So Rogers found Gillooly/Stone easier than Harding.

To Rogers’ amazement, he agreed to meet with him.

“I think it was because his wife liked the movies I wrote, that was my in,” Rogers said.

Rogers was even more amazed that Stone said he didn’t want any money for the interview. The two sat down for one day and talked about Harding.

“He didn’t want to profit on it,” Rogers said. “That’s not how he was portrayed in the media. I genuinely liked him.”

Rogers was convinced the best way to write the screenplay was to tell it from the point of view of both Harding and Gillooly. (He couldn’t find Harding’s mother so Rogers created the character through research and Harding’s recollections. Shawn Eckardt, Harding’s bodyguard who was also involved in the attack on Kerrigan, died in 2007). He wanted to go beyond how the media had portrayed them but also not tell the story as a standard biopic. For a writer who only knew how to write for Hollywood, it was thrilling. He had characters talk to the screen in mid performance. There’s even one point when Harding’s mother criticizes the filmmakers for keeping her out of the story for a long stretch of time.

“All the characters were very rebellious in their own way, but also very wrong-headed, and I wanted the screenplay to mirror that,” Rogers said.

That included bringing out the domestic abuse that Harding alleges her mother and Gillooly inflicted on her. “Life’s not one thing, why can’t you be funny and tragic?” Rogers said. “To me, you can. You don’t know if you should laugh, that’s what we were going for.”

1- Tonya Harding (Margot Robbie) after landing the triple axel in I, TONYA, courtesy of NEON and 30WEST NEON / 30WEST NEON / 30WEST / 30WEST

For all these reasons, Rogers knew when he was done with the script at the beginning of 2016 he could not send it to the studios. He couldn’t bear seeing all the work he put in get gutted. For the first time ever in his career he went the independent film route and quickly found Brian Unkeless (the Hunger Games franchise) as a producing partner. But there were a few caveats before he took it out on the market: there couldn’t be rewrites without his consent, and Allison Janney had to play the role of Harding’s mother.

“I have always written parts for Allison in all my scripts,” Rogers said. He has known the actress for most of his adult life. “She’s never gotten to play a part that I’ve written for her.”

Rogers didn’t just get all his requests, but also Margot Robbie. The actress was hot off her breakout role in The Wolf of Wall Street and searching for movies that could be star vehicles for her when she came across Rogers’ script. She jumped on board to star as Harding and also be a producer.

They chose Craig Gillespie (The Finest Hours) as the director and Rogers said over the 31-day shoot, very little from the script was changed. The movie was bought for around $5 million following its world premiere at this year’s Toronto International Film Festival.

By this time Rogers had become close with both Harding and Gillooly. He invited Harding to see the movie once it was completed. He did not watch it with her.

“I let her see it on her own,” Rogers said, adding that he’s also setting up a time when Gillooly can also see it. “Tonya emailed me twice to thank me. She said she laughed, she cried, there were things she didn’t like, but she was happy.

Harding attended the premiere of the movie.

Rogers can’t tell yet what the success of I, Tonya has done for him. He’s never been involved with a movie that’s received award season buzz like this is, or ever been asked to do press for a movie. Hollywood has taken notice, though. He says now instead of being offered rom-coms, he’s getting scripts about every misunderstood woman from the 1990s.

“It’s like, I, Lorena or I, Monica, I mean really?” Rogers said with a laugh, referring to women who, like Harding, also grabbed the media spotlight in the 1990s — Lorena Bobbitt and Monica Lewinsky.

“Right now, I’m just enjoying the ride.”

– Jason Guerrasio, Business Insider

The42 has just published its first book, Behind The Lines, a collection of some of the year’s best sports stories. Pick up your copy in Eason’s, or order it here today (€10):

Published with permission from
Business Insider
Your Voice
Readers Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel