Wednesday 1 February 2023 Dublin: 9°C
# comparison
Ranking all Liverpool's Premier League managers from worst to best
From Graeme Souness to Brendan Rodgers, we rate each of the Anfield club’s modern-day coaches.

Updated at 23.48

7. Graeme Souness

European Soccer - UEFA Cup - FC Swarovski Tirol v Liverpool EMPICS Sport EMPICS Sport

IN SOUNESS’ DEFENCE, he had a difficult task on his hands replacing an ageing squad and trying to modernise Liverpool in a rapidly changing football era, but the Anfield legend made mistakes by his own admission, and didn’t help his cause by falling out with a number of current and former players. He oversaw the beginning of Liverpool’s decline and was effectively the David Moyes of his day, and for those reasons, deserves his low ranking on this list.

6. Roy Hodgson

Britain Soccer Premier League AP / Press Association Images AP / Press Association Images / Press Association Images

Didn’t have much time to make an impact (Hodgson left after less than one year in charge). Some poor signings (Joe Cole, Paul Konchesky) and bad results, coupled with his appointment as manager being a less than popular one in the first place, ensured an early exit for the current England boss.

5. Kenny Dalglish

Britain Soccer Kenny Dalglish AP / Press Association Images AP / Press Association Images / Press Association Images

By no means a total disaster — Dalglish was sacked just a year after he was appointed on a permanent basis despite overseeing a League Cup triumph as well as the signing of Luis Suarez. Some disappointing results sealed his fate, though his questionable handling of the Suarez-Evra controversy probably didn’t help matters.

4. Roy Evans

FA Cup Final, Manchester United v Liverpool EMPICS Sport EMPICS Sport

Often unfairly slated, Evans renewed life into a Liverpool side that had looked to be on a downward slope, placing faith in several promising young players in the process. The Reds did come close to winning the league during Evans’ tenure, but ultimately ended up with just a solitary League Cup win over the course of his regime. The subsequent appointment of Gerard Houllier as joint-manager was the beginning of the end for the Liverpool-born coach.

3. Brendan Rodgers

Exclusive Six
Nations Analysis

Get Murray Kinsella’s exclusive analysis of Ireland’s Six Nations campaign this spring

Become a Member

Britain Soccer Rodgers Out AP / Press Association Images AP / Press Association Images / Press Association Images

Will be remembered primarily for the 2014 season when Liverpool came desperately close to winning the league, however a failure to live up to that incredible campaign thereafter ultimately cost the Antrim native his job.

2. Gerard Houllier

Soccer - FA Barclaycard Premiership - Liverpool Press Conference Neal Simpson Neal Simpson

Another who is often unfairly maligned, Houllier had an impressive trophy haul in comparison to the other managers on this list, including one particularly impressive campaign that saw the Reds win the League Cup, FA Cup and Uefa Cup. With the help of caretaker boss Phil Thompson, who stepped in when the Frenchman needed emergency heart surgery, he also led them to a rare second-place finish in the 2001-02 campaign.

1. Rafa Benitez

Portugal Soccer Europa League AP / Press Association Images AP / Press Association Images / Press Association Images

Led Liverpool to four consecutive top-four finishes during his reign as well as the improbable feat of winning the Champions League in his first campaign in charge at the club. Consequently, he fully deserves his place at the top of this list.

‘Those days couldn’t have happened without him’ – How the media reacted to Rodgers’ exit>

How well do you remember Brendan Rodgers’ reign as Liverpool manager?>

Your Voice
Readers Comments