Ireland players training on Monday. James Crombie/INPHO

Only victory over Kosovo will allow Ireland manager define bruising year on his own terms

Final preparations for must-win game disrupted as coach Paddy McCarthy returns for Crystal Palace duty.

THERE ARE THINGS a manager says or does when his team are winning that simply don’t get a chance to mushroom into something more serious.

Results set the mood. A squad delivering on the pitch, by and large, will be a happy one. They will remain unaffected by most events that take place outside what they often refer to as “the bubble.”

We’ve heard quite a lot about not allowing “the noise” hinder preparation. Well, what happens when an important voice is absent?

When you pick up five points from a possible 15, as has been the case in this Nations League campaign, and when draws become defeats or wins slip away entirely, then any little grievance or issue can grow legs.

Heimir Hallgrímsson is experienced enough to know the lay of the land. He’s had some difficult decisions to make when it comes to squad selection, the type that might seem completely insignificant on the outside but could go some way to becoming a talking point inside.

You’d wonder, then, just what kind of message it sends out for first-team coach Paddy McCarthy to have to skip the final training session on the eve of this must-win game with Kosovo in Dublin?

heimir-hallgrimsson Ireland manager Heimir Hallgrímsson. James Crombie / INPHO James Crombie / INPHO / INPHO

Hallgrímsson never mentioned the change in his pre-match press conference, and there was no official FAI communication informing anyone of what was happening.

Perhaps they simply hoped no one would notice?

The Ireland manager has at times started press conferences with a pre-prepared speech to make sure he hits on certain key points. If he wanted to make sure people were aware of McCarthy’s absence he could have done so.

Only for McCarthy’s employers, Crystal Palace, released photographs of him working alongside new boss Thomas Frank at the club’s training ground in London, this development would have slipped through the cracks.

Ahead of the 1-0 defeat in Austria on Saturday, Hallgrímsson spoke of a new “growth mindset” that he and the Irish set-up where embracing. He spoke of challenging every member of staff – players, coaches, medical, even kit men – to do more than just “tick their boxes” while in camp.

This seems like a bit of a departure from such focus.

McCarthy is regarded by some on the football leadership team in the FAI as the best coach at any level they have on their books, even if he’s not actually employed on the same kind of contract as Hallgrímsson and assistant head coach John O’Shea.

McCarthy’s deal only covers the international windows. The FAI have been bracing themselves for the moment when they might lose the highly-rated Dubliner, which perhaps explains why Peter Shuttleworth has been back in the fold over the last week.

The former Sheffield Wednesday coach was part of the ticket while O’Shea was in interim charge in 2024.

The FAI had enough experience of upheaval under Hallgrímsson’s predecessor, Stephen Kenny, given the likes of Damien Duff, Anthony Barry and John Eustace came and went.

McCarthy is a popular figure, and it’s understandable that the demands of his full-time job would require him to return to provide support for his new boss. The timing just brings a level of uncertainty Hallgrímsson and the FAI could do without.

Ireland, of course, must beat Kosovo in Dublin to ensure a March play-off for a shot at promotion to League A. Crucially, victory would also secure a place in pot two of the Euro 2028 qualifying draw on 6 December.

That was the stated aim of Hallgrímsson when he made one of those speeches to media before taking questions after naming his squad for the four-game window that kickstarted this campaign.

Maintaining the equilibrium within the squad is a tricky balancing act, but it’s easier for any manager when the team is getting results.

Just like a year ago, when Ireland produced a win for the ages against Hungary in Budapest, everything comes down to this game against Kosovo.

McCarthy is understood to have returned to camp for tonight’s game and a positive outcome will allow Hallgrímsson to define a bruising year in his own terms.

He already attempted to do so on Monday by stressing again just how crucial the May international camp was, citing how it allowed Ireland to blood a talent like Jack Moylan. The Dubliner has made the green jersey his own.

Of course, that May camp only took on such an experimental focus because Ireland were beaten in their World Cup play-off semi-final away to Czechia.

Somehow, Budapest feels like it was yesterday but it’s as if Prague belongs to a different age. Events in Czechia have set the tone for Ireland in the Nations League.

troy-parrott Troy Parrott (left) in training on Monday. James Crombie / INPHO James Crombie / INPHO / INPHO

From a position of strength and control, Ireland ultimately couldn’t triumph. If they can get the job done against Kosovo then Hallgrímsson will feel his men have shown their ability to triumph under pressure yet again.

There is also a doomsday scenario for Ireland tonight. If Kosovo win in Dublin and Israel earn their first victory in Debrecen against already-promoted Austria, the Boys in Green will be relegated to League C.

There will be no positive spin with that, and then the conversations heading into 2027 will feel much different to the sense of hope this year began with.

Possible Republic of Ireland starting XI: Caoimhín Kelleher; James Abankwah, Dara O’Shea (captain), John Egan, Liam Scales, Ryan Manning; Jayson Molumby, Conor Coventry, Jack Moylan, Adam Idah; Troy Parrott.

Tonight: Republic of Ireland v Kosovo, 7.45pm (Live on RTÉ 2).

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel