©INPHO/Gary Carr

No scrum, no win? Stats paint stark picture of Ireland's task against Boks

South Africa have dominated most teams with their potent, powerful scrum.

IT TURNS OUT that the ‘no scrum, no win’ mantra that is much loved in French rugby isn’t completely true.

Les Bleus were the latest side to have their scrum dismantled by South Africa last Friday night in Paris, but Fabien Galthié’s men emerged with a victory. Just about.

Whatever about Rassie Erasmus’ decision to make a late switch of his entire front row before the match – which was “not in the spirit of the game,” in some people’s view – the reality is that the Springboks once again enjoyed total domination of the scrum.

Given what happened in Dublin a year ago when the South African pack took Ireland’s scrum to the cleaners, last weekend was a sharp reminder of the challenge ahead for the Irish forwards this Saturday.

South Africa were awarded a whopping eight scrum penalties against France, who didn’t earn a single scrum penalty in the game, according to Opta’s data. 

The Boks had a remarkable 33% success rate when France fed the ball into the scrum, showing their threat on both sides of the contest.

Ireland scrum coach John Fogarty said recently that he has made a tweak to his coaching approach whereby he shows his players fewer clips of the opposition set-piece in the build-up to Tests. 

Ireland will want to vastly improve on their efforts from last year, of course, so they need to look back, but it might be smart not to dwell on too much of the footage of the Boks’ dominance in that game in November 2025. 

South Africa won six scrum penalties that night against Ireland, who didn’t win any scrum penalties in the game. The figure of six doesn’t include scrum penalty advantages that the Springboks played off.

ireland-and-south-africa-players-contest-a-scrum-during-the-quilter-nations-series-match-at-the-aviva-stadium-dublin-picture-date-saturday-november-22-2025 A scrum in Dublin last year. Alamy Alamy

There was also a scrum penalty awarded to the Springboks by referee Matthew Carley, as well as yellow cards for Irish loosehead props Andrew Porter and Paddy McCarthy. The scrum was absolutely the defining feature of the South Africans’ 24-13 win.

“They did a really good job of lifting our hooker’s left shoulder and getting in underneath,” said former Leinster and Ireland hooker James Tracy on The 42 Rugby Weekly podcast. “We just could not stop it.

“And we kept losing our connection with the second rows. So the front row and hooker’s hips, as you get lifted up, hips kind of straighten and come through, your bum loses connection with the second rows, and all the force just flies through.

“And you’re toast, especially against a very, very strong side.”

It should be noted that Ireland lost second row James Ryan to a 20-minute red card just 20 minutes into the match, which accentuated the absence of the strong-scrummaging lock Joe McCarthy, who was injured at the time.

Ryan’s red card left Ireland with a second row of Ryan Baird and Tadhg Beirne, which wasn’t seen as their strongest scrummaging set-up, while centre Bundee Aki even packed down in a few scrums when Ireland were down to 14 players.

That said, the South African scrum dominance had already started before Ryan’s departure, with the Irish pack marched backwards for a South African penalty advantage in the ninth minute, with the Boks playing off that platform.

That game a year ago remains extremely relevant ahead of this weekend’s clash, but the scale of the task ahead of Ireland is underlined by the scrum data for both teams since that most recent meeting.

In the intervening period, South Africa have averaged 3.42 scrum penalties won per game, which is almost a full penalty per game more than second-best England on 2.55.

Ireland are fifth of all 12 Nations Championship countries with 1.30 scrum penalties awarded to them per game, but the figures in terms of scrum penalties conceded are more concerning.

South Africa, again, have clearly been the best team in the world in this regard over the past year, conceding an average of only 0.58 scrum penalties per game.

In contrast, Ireland’s 1.80 scrum penalty concessions per game have them better off only than Wales, France and Fiji in terms of the Nations Championship countries during the last year of Test rugby.

In terms of scrum penalty difference between penalties won and conceded, South Africa are top of the pile with 2.84 per game, whereas Ireland are mid-table with a difference of -0.50.

Further underlining the effectiveness and the importance of the South African scrum is the fact that they don’t just use it to win penalties. No one else in international rugby has been using the scrum as a better platform for scoring tries over the past year.

The Springboks score an average of 0.83 tries per game on first phase from scrums, with Ireland well down that list at 0.10.

So the statistics amplify the impression from watching these two teams over the past year. South Africa have continued to dominate at scrum time, while Ireland have not.

It remains to be seen what happens this weekend, but Ireland will hope to earn favourable decisions from English referee Christophe Ridley, who was an assistant last weekend in Paris when South Africa played France.

Ridley will be assisted by Angus Gardner of Australia and England’s Anthony Woodthorpe, with assistant referees entitled to convey scrum decisions from the touchline.

It seems certain that Ireland will use their pre-match allotment of five video clips that are shared with the match referee to flag elements of the South African scrum that they believe to be questionable, but we know that referees naturally respond to the power of the Boks’ scrum by rewarding it.

When the South Africans get rolling forward, it creates an irresistible impression and usually results in deserved penalty wins.

So Ireland will have discussed making a big impression in the earliest exchanges at the scrum, where the Boks are hoping to make big gains once again, even if they weren’t totally happy in Paris.

stade-de-france-saint-denis-france-13th-nov-2026-nations-championship-rugby-union-france-versus-south-africa-the-springbok-scrum-and-cameron-hanakom-lifting-the-turf-from-behind-the-scrum-credi A South African scrum against France. Alamy Alamy

“Last week, we thought we did pretty well in the scrums and then at some stage, the rewards just didn’t come anymore, so I guess that’s very human that referees are not going to keep on penalising the same thing,” said head coach Erasmus in Dublin on Monday.

“It’s tough when you’re in front of a crowd where there’s 80,000 people, and you feel the heat of the moment.

“I think we’ll have to be clever this game, because I don’t think Porter or Furlong is bad scrummagers. And I don’t know if the hooker [Dan Sheehan], is he back from HIA or not? Obviously, the hooker they played last week [Rónan Kelleher] is very good. They’ve got solid locks, maybe a few youngsters in the loose forwards, but there’s a solid pack.

“On the day, we got them last year. Hopefully we do again, but there’s no way that they’re sitting there and thinking, ‘We’re going to get smashed’. They sit there and think, ‘OK, we’re going to make a plan now to get through this, and make plans around that, and we must try and nullify that.’

“Obviously, we would love to have dominance there, but it doesn’t come just by hoping.”

Ireland would be happy if there are relatively few scrums in this game.

The Boks can change that part of the picture by opting to scrummage when they are awarded penalties around the pitch, as happened repeatedly last year, even from positions where they could have handily kicked three points.

South Africa did that against France last weekend too, although Erasmus wondered whether his side should have just started to take shots at goal, given his perception that referee Andrea Piardi stopped giving them scrum penalties later in the game.

“I think reading the vibe and where the ref is, not because he’s not a good ref but because he’s now penalising them so many times, will he penalise them once more?” said Erasmus.

“Sometimes you must think, humanly, he’s going to stop penalising them. No ref is going to give one team 35 penalties or 25 penalties. He will stop somewhere. It will get evened up. It’s just human.”

a-general-view-of-a-scrum Ireland won four scrum penalties against Fiji. Ben Brady / INPHO Ben Brady / INPHO / INPHO

As for Ireland’s part in avoiding more scrums, of which there were a whopping 20 last year in Dublin, it will be interesting to see how they approach the game tactically.

Ex-Ireland and Leinster hooker Tracy suggested that Ireland’s overall game plan should strongly consider how to avoid more scrums.

“You start with your kick strategy,” said Tracy.

“The kick strategy, in my opinion, is going to be ‘long and on.’ We don’t want to give them scrums and we don’t want to give them mauls, so how do we reduce our chances of doing that.

“The more contestable kicks there are, the more chances of a knock-on there are. And then the more lineouts you give them, the more chances there are of them mauling back at you.

“So if I’m setting the plan, I’m kicking it long and on the field with a hard chase line. What they do, you have no control over. If they send it back with a contestable, then fine, at least you’ve taken out 50% of the chance of contestables and scrums.”

Tracy believes that Ireland will be better set up to actually scrummage against the Boks this time, given that Joe McCarthy is back from injury, Ryan hopefully won’t be red-carded, and Ireland’s props – who won four scrum penalties against Fiji last weekend – are in good form.

“Do I think we’ll win the scrum battle? No,” said Tracy.

“But do I think it will be more than four or five penalties against us in the worst-case scenario? I don’t think so.

“We will have put so much thought and effort into this part of the game. It’s not going to be the be-all and end-all that it was in last year’s game.”

All eyes will be on that first scrum on Saturday.

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel