Ireland assistant coach Simon Easterby. Tom O'Hanlon/INPHO

'Not in the spirit of the game' - Easterby on Springboks' front row switch

The Ireland assistant coach also said Dan Sheehan is a live option to play at number eight this weekend.

IF WE’RE KEEPING score on press conferences as forms of entertainment, South Africa have struck the first blow this week.

Rassie Erasmus’ explosive remarks in a Dublin hotel on Monday afternoon quickly rippled beyond this island and became the talk of the rugby world.

A few hours earlier, north of the Liffey, Ireland’s Monday press dealings had failed to create the same shockwaves.

The closest we came was when assistant coach Simon Easterby was asked about South Africa’s decision to switch their named starting and replacement front rows shortly before kicking off against France on Friday – and how the prospect of a similar move this week might impact Ireland’s analysis leading into the game.

“It’s been done before. That’s not really my thing,” said Easterby.

“I guess that’s their approach and I’m not saying it’s not in the spirit of the game, but maybe it’s not in the spirit of the game, that’s just the way it is.”

A slight dig, but perhaps not enough to pin on a dressing room wall.

Instead, Erasmus’ comments will set the agenda for the rest of the week. In truth, Ireland have bigger issues to be focusing on. The feeling is that if Ireland are to beat South Africa on Saturday, they’ll need to produce their best performance of the year.

simon-easterby Easterby was speaking to the media in Dublin on Monday. Ben Brady / INPHO Ben Brady / INPHO / INPHO

Accuracy and discipline are the keys. Ireland must be clinical and can’t afford to allow errors creep into their game, thus handing the Springboks more opportunities to show their power in the scrum, and need to stay on the right side of the referee. At one point in last November’s defeat to the Springboks, Ireland were reduced to 12 players – with James Ryan, Sam Prendergast, Jack Crowley and Andrew Porter all sent to the sideline over the course of the 80 minutes.

“Trying to keep 15 on the pitch would be helpful,” Easterby admitted.

“Making sure you are as disciplined as you can be, not to give them access points. Physically, you’ve got to match them, if not better than better that. You know it’s easier said than done.

“But we’ve shown in the past when we have been a match for them and better than them, we’ve delivered a physical performance both sides of the ball that has stopped them getting the type of momentum that, when they do get it, they’re a difficult team to play against.”

And of course, that November 2025 meeting is best remembered for the schooling Ireland were handed at scrum time. It goes without saying that Ireland need a stronger scrum showing this time around, but it was put to Easterby that while the French scrum struggled in the face of that fierce South African pressure on Friday, Fabien Galthié’s men still managed to win the game. Likewise, Ireland won a 2023 World Cup pool game against South Africa despite a badly malfunctioning lineout.

rassie-erasmus Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus. Tom O'Hanlon / INPHO Tom O'Hanlon / INPHO / INPHO

“There’s lots of elements of the game, isn’t there? Sometimes, not one element will win you the game. It’s probably backing up other bits as well, and sometimes a side might have an ascendancy in one area, but then they don’t get the other bits right.

“So the game balances out a little bit. Certainly, we know that setpiece against all the top sides is really important for foundation, for attack, to be effective in defence, but also we know that we’re trying to play a style of rugby which is about us attacking the space and trying to be positive with the ball in hand.

“We’ve seen that certainly at times against Fiji, probably more so against Argentina. We feel like when we’re in that space, attacking-wise, we can beat any side. So sometimes you don’t have to have a perfect element of every area.

“It’s very unusual if you do, but if you lose one bit, then you need to make sure the other bits are much better.”

With James McNabney ruled out, Ireland’s number eight stocks have taken another blow – the Ulster player joining Caelan Doris, Jack Conan and Sean Jansen on the unavailable list. Andy Farrell has opted against calling up further cover, while allowing Ulster back row Dave McCann join Mark Sexton’s Ireland A squad.

Nick Timoney could hold on the eight shirt having moved across from openside flanker for the Fiji win, but the shortage opens up the possibility of returning captain Dan Sheehan doing a job in the Ireland back row, having recently made his first start in the position for Leinster.

nick-timoney-is-tackled-by-selestino-ravutaumada-on-the-way-to-scoring-his-sides-seventh-try-of-the-match Nick Timoney started at No 8 against Fiji. Dan Clohessy / INPHO Dan Clohessy / INPHO / INPHO

“I think you have to consider all those possibilities because of where we’re at in terms of that position in particular. So it certainly wasn’t a bad thing from our perspective that he had a run out there for Leinster.”

Sheehan’s turn at eight came in Leinster’s URC defeat of Munster last month – a strong showing for a first run out in the position.

“I think he felt a bit fresher, maybe a bit freer from not having to scrummage and maul as much.

“He probably felt he then had a good understanding of what players in other positions are doing, but certainly it probably gave him a little bit more of a freedom to carry the way he does so effectively but without the pressures of the scrum and some of the lineout stuff to deal with.”

Ireland have two wins under their belt this November, but are yet to convince across a mixed 2026. South Africa have a greater body of work behind them coming into the game, having played a four-game series against New Zealand as well as Tests against Argentina and Australia across August and September.

dan-sheehan-prepares-for-a-scrum Dan Sheehan played at number eight for Leinster last month. Ben Brady / INPHO Ben Brady / INPHO / INPHO

“They’ve played so much international rugby, haven’t they, of late? It’s almost like a club side, so they’re very familiar with each other, and they’ll be familiar with systems, and they do what they do really well.

“It’s one of those things of you know they force teams to have to go and try and stop that. So you know they have the power game, the setpiece game, but they also have some incredible one-on-one athletes that that can break the game up.

“It’s a pretty impressive unit. They’ve obviously taken a beating against France, and France showed in many ways some of the elements of how to beat them.”

Which is another consideration to throw into the mix. While this can be viewed as a wounded South Africa coming to Dublin, the result in Paris was a reminder the Boks can be beaten – having also lost to the All Blacks and Wallabies in recent months.

“I don’t think we’re too concerned about that. It’s more that we saw things in that French performance that we feel like the French stayed in the fight at times. It was to and fro, it was back and forth.

“There was lots of ball in play, and games like that, they can fall either way. There’s often not one thing that swings it. It’s three or four moments that France stayed in the game and stayed in the fight, that allowed them to get the result.

“So we’re going to make sure that we’re really on it for the full 80 because that’s how good they are. France showed on Friday how good South Africa can be but that if they stay in the fight then anything’s possible.”

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel