Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
Rucks, recycling, and isolated attackers: Is hurling in need of surgery?
PÁDRAIC MAHER SUMMED up Thurles Sarsfields and Inagh Kilnamona’s extra-time battle post-match.
“It wasn’t the prettiest hurling at times, but my God, it was effort and commitment and everything you want from a club team.”
Aside from the full-blooded exchanges, a standout feature of the Munster Club semi-finals was rucks, and lots of them, closely followed by handpasses as teams repeatedly recycled possession at the back.
One colleague characterised the experience as a sport badly in need of change.
Have things really got that bad? First, let’s air the prosecution’s case.
The recycling
Ballygunner’s victory over Kilmallock was notable for the amount of possession recycled around the back.
As early as the third minute, with the Gunners working the sliotar down the right wing, Harry Ruddle turned and struck the sliotar from the 45 back to goalkeeper Stephen O’Keeffe on the 14.
Before half-time, Ballygunner played 12 consecutive sideways passes within 30 metres of their own goal as Kilmallock pressed up. There was the unusual sight of Peter Hogan and O’Keeffe swapping the sliotar back and forth in the corner.
Hogan’s final pass missed the goalie, but the Limerick side stepped over the sideline. That sideline cut then went back to an unmarked O’Keeffe on the endline for an uncontested out-ball.
Ballygunner’s goal began with Philip Mahony and Paddy Leavey taking turns passing backwards to O’Keeffe before they worked the ball forward.
Kilmallock’s goal originated from Tadhg Foley being turned over inside his 14 as he headed towards his own goal seeking the out-ball. Shane O’Brien robbed the sliotar and Oisín O’Reilly finished.
The outnumbered attackers
The scoreless period from minutes 43 to 51 in Ennis showed it on repeat. Thurles Sarsfields had wrestled the upper hand in defence, but their long deliveries repeatedly hit 1v3 or 2v4 contests.
When two Inagh-Kilnamona defenders collided under the 1v3 dropping ball, the third was there to mop up with the keeper behind for further protection. Moments later, when Éamonn Foudy left the sliotar behind him, they had the extra numbers to avoid punishment.
In one moment during that stretch, Sars had 10 players inside their 45 against the Clare champions’ four.
The Tipp side were right to set up as they did, withdrawing an attacker to mirror the hosts’ approach. They learned from Glen Rovers’ mistakes in that regard, not allowing Aidan McCarthy’s positioning on the left flank to contort them out of shape.
It resulted in a congested middle and inside attackers fighting against the odds. Inagh-Kilnamona’s starting full-forward line were withdrawn by the 58th minute. Sars’ inside line were withdrawn by extra-time.
Only one starting forward on each inside line worked the scoreboard. For Kieran Rossiter (0-4) and Conner Hegarty (0-3), their withdrawals were more to do with the sheer amount of running they’d done. The latter was reintroduced in extra-time.
The rucks
Both games featured a collection of these 20-second rolling contests for possession, where a scrum of players congregated for a prolonged bout of prodding at the sliotar.
Even when the ball was liberated from the turf, the handpass to safety didn’t always reach its target, resulting in another spell of ground warfare.
The conditions
Here’s a simple case for the defence. It’s winter hurling. Provincial championships have forever been this way once the weather turns and will remain this way forevermore.
Take a look back. De La Salle won the 2008 and 2010 Munster finals with a combined score of 2-18. Their 2010 victory over Sars was on a 0-9 to 0-8 scoreline in the depths of winter. Loughmore-Castleiney won the 2007 title by scoring 1-6 in the final.
While Cusack Park was heavy underfoot this weekend, if the Munster final ends up at Páirc Uí Chaoimh, it will be a whole other ball game.
Trial rules
Beyond the weather and pitches, coaching and tactics have long been feeding into the rucks and backward play evident at club level.
Seeing isolated attackers battle against a defensive swarm was the best argument for a three-up rule. However, forwards would have to be confined closer to goal than the halfway line in football to have a real effect. The 45 feels too restrictive a boundary, but might coax half-forward lines to advance a fraction more.
A ban on the backpass to the goalkeeper would prevent easy out-balls, encouraging opponents to press up.
The John Meyler-led hurling expert advisory group has gone a different route with their recommendations, which now appear unlikely to come into effect for next year.
We remain sceptical on handpass limits and the minimum distance for puck-outs, but trials are certainly worthwhile beyond the current third-level leagues.
The architects of the trial rules hope that allowing an increase in steps from four to six and a clampdown on spare-hand tackling would enable players to avoid rucks. You’ll find no quibbles here with those amendments.
The much-praised football rules were trialled and tweaked across a calendar year, so hurling deserves similar careful consideration before decisions are made.
Right now, the issues are clearer than the solutions.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Ballygunner Clare GAA GAA Hurling Inagh-Kilnamona Kilmallock Limerick GAA Munster Club SHC Munster GAA New Rules Thurles Sarsfields Tipperary GAA trial rules Waterford GAA