Ireland out-half Sam Prendergast. Tom Maher/INPHO

Sam Prendergast set for disciplinary hearing on Tuesday evening

The Ireland out-half was cited for a hip drop tackle against Fiji.

IRELAND OUT-HALF Sam Prendergast’s disciplinary case remains in progress, with a hearing set to take place at 8pm on Tuesday evening.

It’s believed that Prendergast and Ireland will contest his citing for a hip drop tackle.

The 42 understands that the 23-year-old was cited for a hip drop tackle against Fiji last weekend, putting his involvement in this Saturday’s Nations Championship clash with South Africa in doubt.

The tackle occurred in the 23rd minute of Saturday’s win against Fiji on Saturday, with Prendergast bringing Peceli Yato to ground. The Fijian captain subsequently scored a try but was forced off with an injury soon after.

The tackle was not addressed by the match officials during the game, but it’s understood that the citing commissioner assigned to the game in Dublin felt it was worthy of a formal citing post-match.

That essentially means the citing commissioner believes that the tackle should have resulted in a red card for Prendergast.

It’s understood that the Nations Championship operates with an expedited sanction process, which means a player who is cited can admit that they have committed foul play, therefore receiving a suspension without a hearing. When a player and their team want to contest the citing, the case goes to a formal hearing.

Given that this is the first-ever citing for a hip drop tackle, it’s believed that this process has been more complicated than usual.

However, it’s understood that the case will progress on Tuesday evening with an independent disciplinary hearing, and that Prendergast and Ireland intend to argue that the out-half’s tackle was not worthy of a red card.

The independent disciplinary committee is expected to be made up of England’s Mike Hamlin and Becky Essex, as well as two-time World Cup referee Wayne Erickson, who hails from Australia.

The matter is nuanced, given that this is the first-ever citing for a hip drop tackle in rugby history.

The hip drop tackle was only outlawed by World Rugby on 1 November, meaning it is an entirely new act of foul play in the sport.

World Rugby defines a hip drop tackle as:

“When a ball carrier…

  • is grasped or tackled from the side or behind, and;
  • the tackler swings round or through the ball carrier, and;
  • drops their hips/body weight down on to the legs or lower limbs of the ball carrier as… they are brought to ground.”

World Rugby’s guidance is that when the tackler grasps and swings round or through the ball carrier “with minimal contact on lower limbs,” the sanction should be a penalty.

But when the tackler grasps and swings round or through the ball carrier with “higher level contact with lower limbs,” then yellow cards and red cards come into play.

World Rugby says the level of danger of each tackle can be decided upon using “all relevant circumstances,” including the following:

  • Level of control
  • Diving or having both feet off the ground
  • Hips dropping onto ball carrier moving at speed
  • Distinct or sudden swing and/or drop action on ball carrier
  • Significance of landing on limb

Australia’s Angus Bell was the first player to be shown a yellow card for a hip drop tackle, when a TMO review resulted in him being sin-binned for a challenge on England’s Immanuel Feyi-Waboso in their Nations Championship game two weekends ago.

Bell’s tackle was then studied by the foul play review officer, who decided that it should not be upgraded to a red card.

However, the citing commissioner for Ireland’s clash with Fiji seemingly believed that Prendergast’s challenge on Yato was worthy of a red card, meaning he was cited.

Springboks boss Rassie Erasmus said on Monday that he thought Prendergast’s tackle should have resulted in a red card during the game against Fiji.

Erasmus predicted that Prendergast would be cleared to play against South Africa.

“We are in the Northern Hemisphere,” said Erasmus.

“I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play.”

Erasmus, who has been banned for six games for his comments on Monday about the match officials in South Africa’s loss to France, expanded on his point about Prendergast later.

“I think the hip drop tackle was terrible, in my opinion, compared to where we were at the World Rugby meetings and all coaches were there except the Irish coach and the French coach,” said Erasmus.

“We had like three hours discussion about the hip drop tackle, hip drop tackle and, you know, it’s weird.

“It’s difficult to understand when the TMO sits there and he sees that. And it was something we discussed at the World Rugby meeting, and the examples of how it is was shown over and over, and we all had input.

“Somebody sees that, and he decides there’s nothing wrong with that. Then you wonder, but all of us coaches sit there and all of us gave input. So when you see that, and you decide that there’s nothing wrong with that, what do the other coaches or the other people, what did Jake [White, Fiji head coach] feel? What did that guy that got injured and got carried off?

“We all thought it’s an immediate red card. Everybody watched the game live because that’s exactly what they said the hip drop tackle is.”

Erasmus later added that “my gut feeling is he’ll play on Saturday.”

It’s understood that the Ireland set-up took a dim view of Erasmus’ comments regarding Prendergast’s tackle.

It remains to be seen whether Prendergast is free to play against South Africa, with a conclusion on his disciplinary case expected to be reached tonight.

Close
Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel