Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
Why Tadhg Furlong was cleared to play after Gavin Coombes' interpro accusation
TADHG FURLONG USED video evidence to convince a disciplinary panel that he did not grab the testicles of Munster number eight Gavin Coombes during Leinster’s interprovincial derby win over Munster at the Aviva Stadium on 24 October.
Tighthead Furlong was cited last month, with Coombes alleging during the game that the Ireland prop had squeezed his testicles during a clear-out action at a breakdown.
However, following a disciplinary hearing, Furlong avoided a ban and was cleared to play for Ireland in this month’s Nations Championship northern series.
The decision of the three-person disciplinary panel — chaired by Welshman Simon Thomas — not to hand Furlong a suspension left many South Africans incensed. Almost exactly a year earlier, Springboks hooker Jan-Hendrik Wessels received an initial nine-game ban, reduced to eight games on appeal, after he was found guilty of grabbing the genitals of Connacht forward Josh Murphy following a similar disciplinary process. Wessels consequently missed South Africa’s Nations Championship game against Ireland in Dublin 12 months ago.
At the Springboks’ media briefing on Monday, during which South African boss Rassie Erasmus talked himself into a six-match ban, the apparent leniency afforded to Furlong in comparison to Wessels was among the frustrations voiced by the back-to-back World Cup-winning head coach.
On Tuesday, the URC released the full 22-page written verdict from Furlong’s 28 October hearing, which revealed the video footage used by Furlong to convince the disciplinary panel of his innocence, as well as Coombes’ concern that he would be villainised for making an accusation against a Test player of Furlong’s standing.
During the 38th minute of the URC interpro at Lansdowne Road, the incident was brought to the attention of referee Andrew Brace by Munster captain Tadhg Beirne, via Coombes. However, the television match official was unable to find evidence of foul play from the broadcast angles available to him.
The incident was subsequently was referred to citing commissioner Peter Ferguson, who formally interviewed Coombes post-match to establish the details of his accusation.
Coombes told Ferguson at the time: “I just went into a defensive breakdown and I felt someone’s hand come up between my legs and grab, and I notified our captain, Tadhg, as soon as the next stoppage. Yeah, I think there’s video footage if you want to look at it.”
Ferguson then asked Coombes for “a little bit more detail as to exactly what happened, how long it happened for, and how it made you feel”.
“Yeah, as I said, I felt a hand come between my legs”, Coombes replied, “and I think I reacted by pushing someone. Yeah, that’s it.”
Ferguson asked Coombes again for how long he believed the incident had occurred, to which Coombes replied: “I’m not sure. It’s hard to know how much time in a game like that, so I’m not sure to be honest.”
Coombes would later provide a written statement on the incident, clarifying that, during the breakdown in question, he “felt someone’s hand come up between my legs and then reach up and grab my testicles.
“Then I felt a firm squeeze of my testicles from the player’s hand which lasted two or three seconds before I could react and push his hand away,” Coombes added.
“I then turned to see who it was and why he was doing such a thing – “I said what the f***”. I then let my captain know what had happened at the next stop of play and he referred it to the referee.
“I also said to the Leinster player after the match, “You know what you did”. He replies, ‘Don’t point your finger at me’ and he offered no apology.”
Coombes was assessed after the match, with Munster’s doctor, Jamie Kearns, saying the 28-year-old reported pain around his “testicle/groin area having felt someone grab the area”. Coombes was cleared of symptoms 36 hours after the game.
Coombes told the disciplinary panel that the contact with his testicles had been “firm and quite painful” and had made him feel “very uncomfortable”.
When he was cross-examined by Furlong’s legal representative, Derek Hegarty, Coombes acknowledged that the reverance with which Furlong is held within Irish rugby had caused him to provide a less detailed account of the incident to citing commissioner Ferguson immediately post-match.
In the written verdict, it’s said that Coombes “described how he felt a lot of pressure upon him, not from any person, but from a recognition of the consequences of making the allegation, because of the player’s high status in the public eye and in Ireland”.
“He described how he was having something of a ‘panic attack’, although qualified this to say he did not mean a full panic attack in the literal/medical sense. He said that he was worried about the consequences of being the victim in this situation.
“He said that, when he made his written statement, he did not feel under as much pressure and was in a ‘better headspace’ to explain matters without emotion clouding what he wanted to say.
“When asked more about this ‘pressure’, he said that he knew social media would play a huge part and that being vilified was a real fear. However, he said he knew what had happened to him. He said he had had time to gather his emotions and had a clear head in which to give the details.”
Coombes informed the panel that had drafted his written statement himself, without any external contribution.
He told the panel that he shook hands with Furlong following Munster’s defeat but that, when he broached the incident with the Ireland tighthead, Furlong replied, “Don’t point your finger at me”. Furlong would later deny that this verbal exchange had occurred.
Referee Andrew Brace was also asked to provide evidence to the panel. Brace, who had not seen the incident that had led to Coombes’ allegation, praised Furlong’s character and described the Leinster man as typically being “a pleasure to referee”.
Furlong was subsequently invited to defend himself. The 34-year-old first played for the committee a series of videos illustrating modern-day ruck technique, seeking to provide context to the incident against Munster.
He was asked if he had committed an act of foul play in order to distract Coombes from attempting to compete for the ball. He insisted that he hadn’t, explaining that his actions were very similar to the other legitimate instances of the ‘hooking a leg’ ruck technique. Furlong added that “it would be nearly impossible to target someone at that speed and with that adjustment”.
Asked to describe the actions of his left hand while it was between Coombes’ legs during his attempted clear-out, Furlong illustrated to the committee “how he had tension in his claw-like hand and forearm, but it was not in a grip. It was cupping the leg to make that ‘lift up motion’ to give the required leverage.”
Asked if there was “a risk he may squeeze, grasp or pull the genitals even if he did not intend to do it” when putting his hand between the legs of another player during a similar clear-out, he said he did not accept there was a risk.
Furlong talked the panel through the ruck in question in significant detail using frame-by-frame footage from the 5 NL Corner broadcast angle. Using these still images, Furlong told the panel that “the wrist and forearm could be seen pointing in a downward direction from his left elbow, which was higher.
“The Player [Furlong] highlighted as the frames were played how the thumb strapping could be seen coming back into view and that as this continued it could be seen that his hand was facing ‘in towards Coombes’ leg’ and even the ‘fingers facing in towards the leg’.
“As Coombes is pushed by Leinster 2 [Rónan Kelleher] and gets back onto his feet, the Player stated his hand could be seen between the legs down around the lower level of Coombes’ shorts line facing towards his leg.
“The Player stated that as Coombes was pushed onto his side and Coombes’ legs closed tight in, around his hand and forearm, there was no movement of any kind to suggest any other movement, and as the legs open, the hand can still be seen facing towards the leg and is removed from the lower shorts-line.”
Furlong reiterated that he was 100% certain that his hand “did not make contact with Coombes’ testicles, unless his hand brushed them on the way in, but accepted some contact could have been made with another part of him”.
Finally, when asked which part of Coombes’ leg his left hand had made contact with, he replied that it would have been “high up on the thigh”.
The disciplinary committee asked whether the frame-by-frame footage of 5 NL Corner could be zoomed in upon, but with this not possible, Furlong was invited to submit close-up still images for the committee to consider during their deliberation.
Furlong’s legal representative, Derek Hegarty, said that the tighthead prop did not accept that he had been in any way reckless in his actions. Hegarty told the committee that, while he accepted that Coombes may have made an honest mistake in his allegation, “The incident occurred with five players in a dynamic passage of play in a fast-moving, elite match. The player was certain he had not intended to make contact or reach or squeeze the testicles”.
Leinster director of operations Guy Easterby also gave Furlong a reverential character reference and noted the “upset and distress” exhibited by the tighthead after the allegation. Easterby said it was “inconceivable” that Furlong would have deliberately targeted Coombes’ testicles.
The disciplinary committee reviewed the images and considered the testimonies of each party before deciding not to suspend Furlong.
It said that Coombes had given an honest account of his recollection of the incident and had not sought to embellish the facts. However, it also noted that because Coombes had been less detailed in his recital of the incident immediately after the game, instead adding details in his subsequent written submission, Furlong was “entitled to call into question the accuracy of Mr Coombes’ evidence”.
The committee also said that video evidence of the incident, initially believed to be “compelling”, had been misinterpreted upon further inspection of available angles as well as Furlong’s testimony.
“The Committee therefore concluded that, on the balance of probabilities, the most likely scenario was that, during the fast-moving and dynamic ruck, Mr Coombes felt pressure applied to his testicles and believed at the time that the Player had grabbed them,” the conclusion of the verdict read.
“The Committee accepted the Player’s account, which can also be seen on the video footage, that as Mr Coombes fell onto his side his legs closed tightly around the Player’s hand and forearm. In the Committee’s view, that is the most likely cause of what Mr Coombes felt: a static, all-round pressure arising from his own legs closing around the Player’s arm, rather than from any grip by the Player’s hand.
“When Mr Coombes then reached down and found the Player’s hand in the general area of his upper thigh and/or genitals, he honestly, but mistakenly, believed that it was the hand which had grabbed and squeezed him.
“Having found as a fact that the Player had not grabbed, squeezed or twisted Mr Coombes’ testicles, the Committee considered, for the sake of completeness, whether the Player had acted recklessly.
“Law 9.27 is directed at grabbing, twisting or squeezing the genitals, which are acts of the hand. Pressure arising incidentally from a lawful clear-out, without any grip, is not the conduct alleged in the Citing Complaint.
“The question of recklessness therefore did not arise.”
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Nations Championship Rugby URC Verdict