Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
Why are we asking you to sign in? Find out more here
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy .
Opinion: Sky television did itself no favours on Monday night
SKY TELEVISION, AND in particular Gary Neville, have received much acclaim this season, but neither could have held their head up high following Monday night’s football coverage.
Neville and his colleagues watched Blackburn get beaten by Wigan – a result that consigned Steve Kean’s men to playing Championship football next year. For most of the game, cries of ‘Kean out’ could be heard from the majority of those in attendance at Ewood Park. Moreover, many of the home fans engaged in protest throughout the game, releasing a chicken onto the pitch (a thinly-veiled reference to the club’s owners, Venky’s) and coming onto the field to confront the players and coaching staff once the match had ended (quite an extreme and ill-advised action admittedly).
Sky, however, treated the protests with the utmost level of condescension. Despite the fact that the fans’ actions were entirely peaceful, the general tone of the coverage seemed to be along the lines of ‘how dare they even question the club’s management’.
Meanwhile, Neville also supported Kean to such an extent that it seemed as if he too was a Blackburn player under pressure not to say anything too controversial.
In reaction to the fans’ anger, the ex-United man replied with the most condescending of remarks, saying “everyone at that club needs to take a holiday”. With such a comment, Neville seemed to imply that the stark level of anger amongst the supporters was merely a heat-of-the-moment reaction to getting relegated, when in reality, the Blackburn supporters have consistently been expressing their disillusionment for months.
(Orr, left, wholeheartedly defended Kean in a post-match interview – Nick Potts/PA Wire/Press Association Images)
Of course, there is nothing wrong per se with Neville backing Kean. Perhaps he genuinely believes he is the right man for the Blackburn job. Yet what was so inept about Monday’s coverage was the complete refusal to engage with the anti-Kean stance. Not once were the unhappy supporters’ arguments analysed in depth, nor was the question asked as to whether the seemingly bizarre decision to sack Sam Allardyce – the manager who had guided the club to mid-table respectability – had, in retrospect, been misguided.
Instead, the focus was largely devoted to the pressure Steve Kean has had to deal with, and the supposedly admirable fashion in which he has conducted himself throughout the ‘terrible ordeal’ the supporters have been putting him through. Essentially, it was as if the supporters’ negative attitude (rather than Kean’s poor management) was to blame for the club’s relegation.
So why did Sky television appear to go easy on the Blackburn management and its owners? It is impossible to definitively say. However, an old boys’ club attitude often seems to permeate English football. Current managers and players regularly serve as guest pundits for Sky and other channels, and therefore, the boundaries between footballers and football analysts are often blurred. Consequently, the result is a clear reluctance on the part of pundits to engage in substantial criticism of those with a first-hand involvement in the beautiful game.
And there is indeed a case in point of this old boys’ club attitude that relates directly to Blackburn and Monday night. Last August, the club’s Indian owners bought Gary Neville’s house for a reportedly handsome fee of £5.5million. Therefore, surely the question must be asked as to whether Neville is capable of objectively analysing a club – especially when said analysis seems so one-sided – if he is doing business deals with the owners away from the glare of the TV cameras.
Read: Here’s what the Irish squad will be bringing to the Euros>
Read: Ben Arfa named in France’s provisional Euro 2012 squad>
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
Blackburn Bradley Orr Chicken conjecture Editor's picks Gary Neville Steve Kean Wigan